| Term | Attorney | Party | Appointed by |
| 1 | April 1815–July 1819 | | Jonathan Fisk | | Democratic-Republican | James Madison |
| 2 | July 1819–February 1828 | | Robert L. Tillotson | | Democratic-Republican | James Monroe |
| 3 | February 1828– April 1829 | | John Duer | | Democratic-Republican | John Quincy Adams |
| 4 | April 1829– April 1834 | | James A. Hamilton | | Democratic | Andrew Jackson |
| 5 | April 1834– December 10, 1838 | | William M. Price | | Democratic |
| 6 | December 1838– March 1841 | | Benjamin F. Butler | | Democratic | Martin Van Buren |
| 7 | March 1841– March 1845 | | Ogden Hoffman | | Whig | William Henry Harrison |
| 8 | March 1845– September 1848 | | Benjamin F. Butler | | Democratic | James Polk |
| 9 | September 1848– December 1848 | | Charles McVean | | Democratic |
| 10 | January 1849–April 1849 | | Lorenzo B. Shepard | | Democratic |
| 11 | April 1849–March 1853 | | Jonathan Prescott Hall | | Whig | Zachary Taylor |
| 12 | April 1853–June 1854 | | Charles O'Conor | | Democratic | Franklin Pierce |
| 13 | July 1854–January 1858 | | John McKeon | | Democratic |
| 14 | January 1858–December 1859 | | Theodore Sedgwick | | Democratic | James Buchanan |
| 15 | December 1859–March 1861 | | James I. Roosevelt | | Democratic |
| 16 | April 1861–April 1865 | | Edward Delafield Smith | | Republican | Abraham Lincoln |
| 17 | April 1865–April 12, 1866 | | Daniel S. Dickinson | | Democratic |
| 18 | April 1866–April 25, 1869 | | Samuel G. Courtney | | Democratic | Andrew Johnson |
| 19 | April 25, 1869–July 20, 1870 | | Edwards Pierrepont | | Republican | Ulysses S. Grant |
| 20 | July 20, 1870–December 31, 1872 | | Noah Davis | | Republican |
| 21 | December 31, 1872–January 24, 1877 | | George Bliss Jr. | | Republican |
| 22 | January 24, 1877–March 12, 1883 | | Stewart L. Woodford | | Republican |
| 23 | March 12, 1883–July 6, 1885 | | Elihu Root | | Republican | Chester A. Arthur |
| 24 | July 6, 1885–March 1, 1886 | | William Dorsheimer | | Democratic | Grover Cleveland |
| 25 | March 1, 1886–September 16, 1889 | | Stephen A. Walker | | Democratic |
| 26 | September 16, 1889–February 1, 1894 | | Edward Mitchell | | Republican | Benjamin Harrison |
| | February 1, 1894–July 23, 1894 | | Henry C. Platt | | Democratic | Grover Cleveland |
| 27 | July 23, 1894–January 1898 | | Wallace Macfarlane | | Democratic |
| 28 | January 1898–January 1906 | | Henry Lawrence Burnett | | Republican | William McKinley |
| 29 | January 1906–April 8, 1909 | | Henry L. Stimson | | Republican | Theodore Roosevelt |
| 30 | April 8, 1909–May 7, 1913 | | Henry A. Wise | | Republican | William Howard Taft |
| 31 | May 7, 1913–April 1917 | | Hudson Snowden Marshall | | Democratic | Woodrow Wilson |
| 32 | April 1917–June 1921 | | Francis Gordon Caffey | | Democratic |
| 33 | June 1921–March 2, 1925 | | William Hayward | | Republican | Warren Harding |
| 34 | March 2, 1925–April 6, 1927 | | Emory Buckner | | Republican | Calvin Coolidge |
| 35 | April 6, 1927–September 29, 1930 | | Charles H. Tuttle | | Republican |
| | September 29, 1930–January 1931 | | Robert E. Manley | | Republican | Herbert Hoover |
| 36 | January 1931–November 21, 1933 | | George Z. Medalie | | Republican |
| | November 22, 1933–December 26, 1933 | | Thomas E. Dewey | | Republican | Franklin D. Roosevelt |
| 37 | December 26, 1933–May 16, 1935 | | Martin Thomas Conboy Jr. | | Democratic |
| | May 16, 1935–November 20, 1935 | | Francis W. H. Adams | | Democratic |
| 38 | November 20, 1935–December 1938 | | Lamar Hardy | | Democratic |
| | December 1938–March 1939 | | Gregory Francis Noonan | | Democratic |
| 39 | March 1939–March 1941 | | John T. Cahill | | Democratic |
| 40 | March 1941–June 10, 1943 | | Mathias F. Correa | | Democratic |
| | June 10, 1943–August 2, 1943 | | Howard F. Corcoran | | Democratic |
| 41 | August 2, 1943–October 9, 1944 | | James B. M. McNally | | Democratic |
| 42 | October 9, 1944–October 1949 | | John F. X. McGohey | | Democratic |
| 43 | October 1949– September 18, 1951 | | Irving Saypol | | Democratic | Harry S. Truman |