| No.overall | No. inseason | Title | Directed by | Written by | Original airdate |
| 1 | 1 | "Coming Home" | Bradley Walsh | Roma Roth & Kerri MacDonald | March 19, 2023 (2023-03-19) |
| Maggie, a neurosurgeon, has some legal trouble in Boston. Her boss has been indicted for billing fraud and she is being sued for negligence. She decides to go home to Timberlake, Nova Scotia. Although people are generally friendly and welcoming, she is stand-offish and her Dad Sully thinks she doesn't really need him and is wary about how long she'll stay. |
| 2 | 2 | "Homewrecker" | Gail Harvey | Adam Pettle | March 26, 2023 (2023-03-26) |
| Maggie is going over her medical files to figure out if or what she did wrong with her negligence case. Sully says it's not about her, it's about a mother losing her child. Later, Sully looks through old photo albums of Maggie and we find out he's a recovering alcoholic. The elderly Roy who suffers from dementia has a fall and Maggie provides first aid. Later that day, Maggie and Sidney are having a few drinks and sing karaoke. Maggie has a beer with Cal after Sidney leaves with a fire fighter and since Maggie is a little drunk, Cal walks her home. When she arrives home, her boyfriend Andrew is waiting for her. He apologises for what he said before she left Boston and they make up. |
| 3 | 3 | "Detours" | Peacocke | Kerri MacDonald | April 2, 2023 (2023-04-02) |
| Andrew wants Maggie to come back to Boston with him but she refuses. Andrew is jealous of Cal because he walked Maggie home. Later that day, Sully's camp site celebrates the season opening with food, music and games and by conducting a ceremony to honour the Mi'kmaq people of the native land. A 16-year-old girl, Chelsea, goes missing and the whole town comes together for the search. Frank comes across two boys, who are visiting the area, drinking and illegally doing target practise in the woods. They have Chelsea with them. Frank tries to get them to leave but then one of the boy's guns goes off and shoots Frank. Chelsea wants to call 911 but the boys are too scared and they run off with the girl. |
| 4 | 4 | "Rock and a Hard Place" | Peacocke | John Callaghan & T'áncháy Redvers | April 9, 2023 (2023-04-09) |
| Some of the townspeople start worrying about Frank's absence so Sully, Cal and Maggie go in search of him. Maggie and Cal find him in the woods and Franks tells them he was accidentally shot by one of the college guys from the campsite. Maggie and Cal find the boys and are able to free Chelsea who is being held in their cabin. Sully has a meeting with his bank asking for another extension on his loan but is told that he has to pay or go into foreclosure by the end of next month. Cal and Maggie are going fishing and he invites her to cook her catch for dinner. Lola admits to Sully that she is overwhelmed with having to care for Roy, and Sully gives her a cheque to make alteration at home and get home care for her grandfather. |
| 5 | 5 | "Pressure Drop" | Gail Harvey | John Callaghan | April 16, 2023 (2023-04-16) |
| Maggie goes to the diner, where Syd says she’s ended her relationship with Rafe and that Finn got kicked out of his baseball tournament for fighting. Frank returns from the hospital. Jackson reads Sully a news article that questions the safety of Sullivan’s Crossing, mentioning that this may be the reason people canceled their reservations. Cal helps Maggie prepare for her deposition and mentions his wife, Lynne, which catches Maggie off guard. Maggie tells Rob about Finn’s fight, leaving Rob angry at Syd. Walter arrives at the campground unannounced, and he reassures Maggie about the upcoming trial. Sully fails to get another loan to save the family land, so he goes to a bar and almost breaks his vow of sobriety. Cal tells Maggie that his wife died of ALS. Sully confronts Walter. Walter admits that he convinced Phoebe to keep Maggie away when she was young, and Sully breaks Walter’s nose. When Walter leaves for Boston, Maggie goes with him. Afterwards, Sully takes a shot of tequila. |
| 6 | 6 | "Boiling Point" | Bradley Walsh | Kerri MacDonald | April 23, 2023 (2023-04-23) |
| At lunch with Phoebe and Andrew, Maggie learns Andrew has accepted the job in Boston. At Sullivan’s Crossing, Cal and Roy discuss Maggie and Lola over a game of chess. Edna confronts Sully about the fight with Walter. Cal has dinner with Roy and Lola. In Boston, Andrew takes Maggie out to celebrate his new job. While she’s in the bathroom, he reads and deletes a text from Cal on her phone. Maggie later runs into her old boss and tells him she never wants to hear from him again. Maggie calls Cal before her deposition and tells him she never got his text. During a break in the deposition, the patient’s mother confronts Maggie. Meanwhile more campers cancel reservations at Sullivan’s Crossing. Maggie calls Sully to tell him the case is going to trial and ends the call angry. Sully drinks again and paints over Maggie’s mural, thinking she’s never coming back. Andrew proposes to Maggie, but they are interrupted by a phone call before she can answer. Maggie tells him she has to go back to Sullivan’s Crossing. |
| 7 | 7 | "Second Chances" | Gail Harvey | Kerri MacDonald & Dee Raffo & Roma Roth | April 30, 2023 (2023-04-30) |
| Maggie returns to Sullivan’s Crossing for Roy’s funeral. Finn fights with another kid, and Rob expresses concern over his behavior. Lola accuses Maggie of hurting Sully every time she comes back. Cal has a flashback to his wife’s death, in which she encourages him to move on with his life after she passes. At the diner, Rob talks with Finn, and Rafe stops in to ask Syd why she’s avoiding him. Rob gives him advice. Lola brings Cal Roy’s chess set. They talk about her childhood accident when she was the victim of a hit and run. Edna and Frank plan a vacation to visit family. Maggie takes Andrew to her favorite spot from her childhood. He says he wants to start a family, but she hesitates. Frank asks Sully to go to an AA meeting, but Sully declines. At the bar later, Andrew picks a fight with Cal, and he admits he deleted Cal’s texts to Maggie. He punches Cal and breaks up with Maggie. Maggie goes home to Sully’s but flees when she sees he has painted over their mural. |
| 8 | 8 | "Aftershock" | Gail Harvey | Roma Roth | May 7, 2023 (2023-05-07) |
| Sully agrees to give Frank a ride to an AA meeting. Syd visits Maggie, and they discuss why she only came back to the camp once as a teen, as well as the breakup. Frank expresses some concerns about leaving Sully alone when he and Edna go on vacation. Maggie checks on Cal, and they talk about the breakup and the upcoming trial. Rafe stops by the diner, and Rob urges Syd to ask Rafe out. The two go out on a date, but she gets uncomfortable when he brings up her past modeling career. Cal takes Maggie into the forest to relax. While there, she has a flashback to the day her mother took her from Sully, but Cal reassures her. They connect over their past trauma. Kaleb gets sick on the way to a rock climb, but Jackson gets Cal and Maggie for help. Kaleb says Jackson should tell Tom, his father, about his dreams to be an architect. Frank and Edna tell Sully they’re leaving on vacation but Jackson and Maggie will stay to help. Cal takes Maggie on a picnic to her favorite spot. Maggie kisses Cal but regrets it. Back at home, Maggie and Sully argue about the past. |
| 9 | 9 | "Can't Help Falling" | Jerry Ciccoritti | John Callaghan | May 14, 2023 (2023-05-14) |
| Maggie and Syd chat about Cal and Rafe. Lola tries to return Sully’s check, but he insists she keep it. She offers to help out at the camp store instead. Maggie apologizes to Lola for misunderstanding her mother’s relationship with Sully. Jackson and Kaleb almost kiss on a rock climb, but then Jackson takes a fall and sustains a serious head injury. Kaleb runs for help. Cal helps Maggie try and save Jackson until the rescue crew arrives. At the diner, Syd advises Rob to spend more time with Finn. Rob interviews people for an assistant manager position, and Syd gets angry that he didn’t discuss it with her first. Jackson’s surgery is successful. Back at camp, Maggie and Sully make peace. Sully calls Phoebe to say that Maggie belongs in Boston where she can make a difference. Maggie’s lawyer calls to say the trial date has been moved up. Sully gets a foreclosure letter for Sullivan’s Crossing. |
| 10 | 10 | "Sins of the Father" | Jerry Ciccoritti | Roma Roth | May 14, 2023 (2023-05-14) |
| Sully considers taking out a second mortgage. When Rob hires an assistant manager, Syd quits and moves out of Rob’s house because she feels unwanted. Kaleb visits the hospital to tell Jackson goodbye. Syd moves in with Rafe, insisting it’s temporary and that they’re not a couple. In Boston, the trial begins, but after Maggie speaks to Mrs. Markiff in private, Mrs. Markiff asks the court to dismiss the suit. After the trial, Andrew apologizes to Maggie. She is offered a job at a Boston hospital. Maggie’s old boss catches up to her and implies Walter has been involved in illegal activity. Maggie returns to Sullivan’s Crossing to consider her future. Cal remembers the day his wife passed away, then spreads her ashes in the ocean. He leaves a note for Maggie before checking out of the cabin, but Lola takes it before Maggie arrives. Back at Sully’s house, Maggie takes a pregnancy test. It’s positive. She decides to take the job in Boston and asks Sully why he never came after her when Phoebe left him. He doesn’t answer, and she leaves. During a flashback, Sully recalls speeding after Phoebe and Maggie in his truck. He loses control and hits Lola, who was riding her bike, revealing that he was responsible for her childhood accident and that this is why he never came for Maggie. His heart races, and he loses consciousness. Maggie pauses at the gates of Sullivan’s crossing before driving away. |
