| Year | Award | Category | Work | Result | Ref. |
| 2021 | Chicago Film Critics Association | Most Promising Performer | West Side Story | Nominated | |
| Florida Film Critics Circle | Pauline Kael Breakout Award | Runner-up | |
| Indiana Film Journalists Association | Breakout of the Year | Nominated | |
| National Board of Review | Best Actress | Won | |
| North Texas Film Critics Association | Best Actress | Nominated | |
| Best Newcomer | Won |
| Washington D.C. Area Film Critics Association | Best Youth Performance | Nominated | |
| 2022 | Alliance of Women Film Journalists | Best Breakthrough Performance | Nominated | |
| Critics' Choice Movie Awards | Best Young Actor/Actress | Nominated | |
| DiscussingFilm Critics Awards | Best Debut Performance | Nominated | |
| Dorian Awards | Rising Star of the Year | Nominated | |
| Imagen Awards | Best Actress | Nominated | |
| Georgia Film Critics Association | Nominated | |
| Breakthrough Award | Nominated |
| Golden Globe Awards | Best Actress in a Motion Picture – Musical or Comedy | Won | |
| Music City Film Critics Association | Best Young Actress | Nominated | |
| North Carolina Film Critics Association | Best Breakthrough Performance | Nominated | |
| Online Film and Television Association | Best Breakout Performance: Female | Nominated | |
| 2024 | People's Choice Awards | Action Movie Star of the Year | The Hunger Games: The Ballad of Songbirds & Snakes | Won | |
| Female Movie Star of the Year | Nominated |
| 2025 | Saturn Awards | Best Performance by a Younger Actor | Nominated | |
| iHeartRadio Music Awards | Favorite Broadway Debut | Romeo + Juliet | Won | |
| Broadway.com Audience Awards | Favorite Leading Actress in a Play | Won | |
| Favorite Breakthrough Performance (Female) | Nominated | |
| Favorite Onstage Pair | Nominated | |
| The Stage Debut Awards | Best West End Debut Performance | Evita | Won | |
| 2026 | Stalls to Stage Awards | Screen Stars on Stage | Pending | |