| Year | Category | Work | Result |
| 2005 | Female Vocalist of the Year | | Nominated |
| Pop/Contemporary Recorded Song of the Year | "Live for Today" | Nominated |
| 2006 | Artist of the Year | | Nominated |
| Female Vocalist of the Year | | Won |
| Song of the Year | "Held" | Nominated |
| Pop/Contemporary Recorded Song of the Year | "Held" | Nominated |
| Pop/Contemporary Album of the Year | Awaken | Nominated |
| Inspirational Album of the Year | Believe | Nominated |
| 2007 | Female Vocalist of the Year | | Won |
| 2008 | Artist of the Year | | Nominated |
| Female Vocalist of the Year | | Won |
| Song of the Year | "In Better Hands" | Nominated |
| Pop/Contemporary Recorded Song of the Year | "In Better Hands" | Nominated |
| 2009 | Female Vocalist of the Year | | Won |
| Song of the Year | "I Will Not Be Moved" | Nominated |
| Pop/Contemporary Recorded Song of the Year | "I Will Not Be Moved" | Nominated |
| Pop/Contemporary Album of the Year for | Relentless | Nominated |
| Worship Song of the Year | "Breathe on Me" | Nominated |
| 2010 | Female Vocalist of the Year | | Nominated |
| 2011 | Artist of the Year | | Nominated |
| Female Vocalist of the Year | | Nominated |
| Pop/Contemporary Album of the Year | | Nominated |
| 2012 | Female Vocalist of the Year | | Won |
| Pop/Contemporary Recorded Song of the Year | "Alive (Mary Magdalene)" | Nominated |
| Special Event Album of the Year | The Story (various artists) | Won |