| Year | Result | Host arena | Host city | Game MVP |
| 1951 | East 111, West 94 | Boston Garden | Boston, Massachusetts | Ed Macauley, Boston Celtics |
| 1952 | East 108, West 91 | Boston Garden (2) | Boston, Massachusetts (2) | Paul Arizin, Philadelphia Warriors |
| 1953 | West 79, East 75 | Allen County War Memorial Coliseum | Fort Wayne, Indiana | George Mikan, Minneapolis Lakers |
| 1954 | East 98, West 93 (OT) | Madison Square Garden III** | New York City, New York | Bob Cousy, Boston Celtics |
| 1955 | East 100, West 91 | Madison Square Garden III** (2) | New York City, New York (2) | Bill Sharman, Boston Celtics |
| 1956 | West 108, East 94 | Rochester War Memorial Coliseum | Rochester, New York | Bob Pettit, St. Louis Hawks |
| 1957 | East 109, West 97 | Boston Garden (3) | Boston, Massachusetts (3) | Bob Cousy (2), Boston Celtics |
| 1958 | East 130, West 118 | St. Louis Arena | St. Louis, Missouri | Bob Pettit (2), St. Louis Hawks |
| 1959 | West 124, East 108 | Olympia Stadium | Detroit, Michigan | Elgin Baylor, Minneapolis LakersBob Pettit (3), St. Louis Hawks |
| 1960 | East 125, West 115 | Convention Hall | Philadelphia, Pennsylvania | Wilt Chamberlain, Philadelphia Warriors |
| 1961 | West 153, East 131 | Onondaga County War Memorial Coliseum | Syracuse, New York | Oscar Robertson, Cincinnati Royals |
| 1962 | West 150, East 130 | St. Louis Arena (2) | St. Louis, Missouri (2) | Bob Pettit (4), St. Louis Hawks |
| 1963 | East 115, West 108 | LA Sports Arena | Los Angeles, California | Bill Russell, Boston Celtics |
| 1964 | East 111, West 107 | Boston Garden (4) | Boston, Massachusetts (4) | Oscar Robertson (2), Cincinnati Royals |
| 1965 | East 124, West 123 | St. Louis Arena (3) | St. Louis, Missouri (3) | Jerry Lucas, Cincinnati Royals |
| 1966 | East 137, West 94 | Cincinnati Gardens | Cincinnati, Ohio | Adrian Smith, Cincinnati Royals |
| 1967 | West 135, East 120 | Cow Palace | Daly City, California | Rick Barry, San Francisco Warriors |
| 1968 | East 144, West 124 | Madison Square Garden III** (3) | New York City, New York (3) | Hal Greer, Philadelphia 76ers |
| 1969 | East 123, West 112 | Baltimore Civic Center | Baltimore, Maryland | Oscar Robertson (3), Cincinnati Royals |
| 1970 | East 142, West 135 | The Spectrum | Philadelphia, Pennsylvania (2) | Willis Reed, New York Knicks |
| 1971 | West 108, East 107 | San Diego Sports Arena | San Diego, California | Lenny Wilkens, Seattle SuperSonics |
| 1972 | West 112, East 110 | The Forum | Inglewood, California | Jerry West, Los Angeles Lakers |
| 1973 | East 104, West 84 | Chicago Stadium | Chicago, Illinois | Dave Cowens, Boston Celtics |
| 1974 | West 134, East 123 | Seattle Center Coliseum | Seattle, Washington | Bob Lanier, Detroit Pistons |
| 1975 | East 108, West 102 | Arizona Veterans Memorial Coliseum | Phoenix, Arizona | Walt Frazier, New York Knicks |
| 1976 | East 123, West 109 | The Spectrum (2) | Philadelphia, Pennsylvania (3) | Dave Bing, Washington Bullets |
| 1977 | West 125, East 124 | Milwaukee Arena | Milwaukee, Wisconsin | Julius Erving, Philadelphia 76ers |
| 1978 | East 133, West 125 | Omni Coliseum | Atlanta, Georgia | Randy Smith, Buffalo Braves |
| 1979 | West 134, East 129 | Pontiac Silverdome | Pontiac, Michigan† | David Thompson, Denver Nuggets |
| 1980 | East 144, West 136 (OT) | Capital Centre | Landover, Maryland | George Gervin, San Antonio Spurs |
| 1981 | East 123, West 120 | Coliseum at Richfield | Richfield, Ohio | Nate Archibald, Boston Celtics |
| 1982 | East 120, West 118 | Brendan Byrne Arena | East Rutherford, New Jersey | Larry Bird, Boston Celtics |
| 1983 | East 132, West 123 | The Forum (2) | Inglewood, California (2) | Julius Erving (2), Philadelphia 76ers |
| 1984 | East 154, West 145 (OT) | McNichols Sports Arena | Denver, Colorado | Isiah Thomas, Detroit Pistons |
| 1985 | West 140, East 129 | Hoosier Dome | Indianapolis, Indiana† | Ralph Sampson, Houston Rockets |
| 1986 | East 139, West 132 | Reunion Arena | Dallas, Texas | Isiah Thomas (2), Detroit Pistons |
| 1987 | West 154, East 149 (OT) | Kingdome | Seattle, Washington† (2) | Tom Chambers, Seattle SuperSonics |
| 1988 | East 138, West 133 | Chicago Stadium (2) | Chicago, Illinois (2) | Michael Jordan, Chicago Bulls |
| 1989 | West 143, East 134 | Astrodome | Houston, Texas† | Karl Malone, Utah Jazz |
| 1990 | East 130, West 113 | Miami Arena | Miami, Florida | Magic Johnson, Los Angeles Lakers |
| 1991 | East 116, West 114 | Charlotte Coliseum | Charlotte, North Carolina | Charles Barkley, Philadelphia 76ers |
| 1992 | West 153, East 113 | Orlando Arena | Orlando, Florida | Magic Johnson (2), Los Angeles Lakers |
| 1993 | West 135, East 132 (OT) | Delta Center§ | Salt Lake City, Utah | Karl Malone (2), Utah JazzJohn Stockton, Utah Jazz |
| 1994 | East 127, West 118 | Target Center | Minneapolis, Minnesota | Scottie Pippen, Chicago Bulls |
| 1995 | West 139, East 112 | America West Arena§ | Phoenix, Arizona (2) | Mitch Richmond, Sacramento Kings |
| 1996 | East 129, West 118 | Alamodome | San Antonio, Texas | Michael Jordan (2), Chicago Bulls |
| 1997 | East 132, West 120 | Gund Arena§ | Cleveland, Ohio | Glen Rice, Charlotte Hornets |
| 1998 | East 135, West 114 | Madison Square Garden*** | New York City, New York (4) | Michael Jordan (3), Chicago Bulls |
| 1999 | Canceled due to the league's lockout.The game was originally set to be played at the First Union Center in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania. |