| Year | Association | Category | Nominated work | Result | Ref |
| 2010 | Academy of Country Music Awards | Top New Solo Vocalist | Himself | Won | |
| Top New Artist | Won | |
| CMT Music Awards | USA Weekend Breakthrough Video of the Year | "Do I" | Won | |
| Country Music Association Awards | New Artist of the Year | Himself | Nominated | |
| 2011 | CMT Music Awards | Best Web Video of the Year | "It's a Shore Thing" | Nominated | |
| Nationwide Insurance On Your Side Award | Himself | Nominated | |
| Country Music Association Awards | New Artist of the Year | Himself | Nominated | |
| Teen Choice Awards | Choice Music: Country Song | "Country Girl (Shake It for Me)" | Nominated | |
| Choice Music: Country Artist Male | Himself | Nominated | |
| American Country Awards | Male Artist of the Year | Nominated | |
| Single by a Male Artist | "Someone Else Calling You Baby" | Nominated |
| 2012 | CMT Music Awards | Video of the Year: Male | "I Don't Want This Night To End" | Won | |
| Teen Choice Awards | Teen Choice Award for Music – Male Country Artist | Himself | Nominated | |
| Country Music Association Awards | Male Vocalist of the Year | Nominated | |
| Album of the Year | Tailgates & Tanlines | Nominated |
| American Music Awards | Favorite Male Country Artist | Himself | Won | |
| Favorite Country Album | Tailgates & Tanlines | Nominated | |
| American Country Awards | Artist of the Year | Himself | Won | |
| Male Artist of the Year | Won |
| Single of the Year | "I Don't Want This Night to End" | Won |
| Single by a Male Artist | Won |
| Music Video of the Year | Won |
| Music Video by a Male Artist | Won |
| Album of the Year | Tailgates & Tanlines | Won |
| Most Played Radio Track | "I Don't Want This Night to End" | Won |
| Most Played Radio Track by a Male Artist | Won |
| 2013 | Academy of Country Music Awards | Entertainer of the Year | Himself | Won | |
| Male Vocalist of the Year | Nominated |
| Album of the Year | Tailgates & Tanlines | Nominated |
| Vocal Event of the Year | "The Only Way I Know" (with Jason Aldean and Eric Church) | Won |
| Billboard Music Awards | Top Country Artist | Himself | Nominated | |
| Top Country Album | Tailgates & Tanlines | Nominated |
| Top Country Song | "Drunk on You" | Nominated |
| CMT Music Awards | Video of the Year | "Kiss Tomorrow Goodbye" | Nominated | |
| Male Video of the Year | Nominated |
| Collaboration Video of the Year | "The Only Way I Know" (with Jason Aldean and Eric Church) | Won |
| CMT Performance of the Year | "Drunk on You"/"Feel Again" (with Ryan Tedder) | Nominated |
| American Music Awards | Favorite Country Male Artist | Himself | Won | |
| Favorite Country Album | Crash My Party | Nominated |
| 2014 | Billboard Music Awards | Top Billboard 200 Album | Crash My Party | Nominated | |
| Top Country Album | Crash My Party | Won |
| Top Male Artist | Himself | Nominated |
| Top Billboard 200 Artist | Nominated |
| Top Country Artist | Won |
| Top Country Song | "Crash My Party" | Won |
| Top Country Song | "That's My Kind of Night" | Nominated |
| Academy of Country Music Awards | Entertainer of the Year | Himself | Nominated | |
| Male Vocalist of the Year | Nominated |
| Album of the Year | Crash My Party | Nominated |