| Pontificate | Common English name | Sculptor | Location | Notes |
| a217–235 | HippolytusSaint Hippolytus | Unknown | Cemetery of Hippolytus | Remains translated to Rome by his rival Pope Fabian; inscription by Pope Damasus I recorded in Orazio Marucchi's Christian Epigraphy |
| b251–258 | Novatian | Unknown | Unknown | Tombstone discovered in 1932 on the Via Tiburtina in Rome with the inscription "blessed martyr Novation"; considered unverified by scholars because the inscription lacks the word "bishop" |
| c355–365 | Felix IISaint Felix | Unknown | Church on Via Aurelia | Martyred and sainted; buried in a church of his making on the Via Aurelia according to Liber Pontificalis |
| d366–367 | Ursicinus | Unknown | Gaul | |
| e418–419 | Eulalius | Unknown | Unknown | Nothing known of death but year |
| f498–499 | Laurentius | Unknown | Unknown | Died on the farm of his patron Festus |
| g530 | Dioscorus | Unknown | Unknown | Memory was officially condemned by Pope Boniface II but reinstated by Pope Agapetus I |
| h687 | Theodore | Unknown | Unknown | Nothing known of him after his concession to Pope Sergius I |
| i687 | Paschal | Unknown | Unknown | Imprisoned in an unknown monastery until his death and buried in an unknown location |
| j766–768 | Constantine II | Unknown | Unknown | Died in an unknown monastery after much corporal mortification at the hands of the followers of Pope Stephen III |
| k768 | Philip | Unknown | Unknown | No historical references after his return to his Monastery of St. Vito (Rome) |
| l844 | John VIII | Unknown | Unknown | Nothing more known after he was confined to a monastery |
| m855 | Anastasius | Unknown | Unknown | |
| n903–904 | Christopher | Unknown | Old St. Peter's Basilica | Interred in Old St. Peter's by his overthrower, Pope Sergius III; destroyed in the seventeenth century demolition of Old St. Peter's; fragment of epitaph recorded by Peter Mallius |
| o984–985 | Boniface VII | Unknown | Unknown | Roman mob seized his corpse, stripped him of his vestments, dragged him through the streets, and deposited it at the feet of a statue of Marcus Aurelius on horseback, at which point he was trampled and stabbed; carried away by clerics at night and buried in an unknown location |
| p997–998 | John XVI | Unknown | Unknown | Bodily mutilated by Pope Gregory V and Otto III, Holy Roman Emperor and confined to a Roman monastery until his death |
| q1012 | Gregory VI | Unknown | Hamburg, Germany | Died in Hamburg; no documentation of funeral or monument exist |
| r1058–1059 | Benedict X | Unknown | Sant'Agnese in Agone | Sarcophagus in the crypt (not open to public) still contains his corpse |
| s1061–1064 | Honorius II | Unknown | Unknown | Died in Parma |
| t1080 | Clement III | Unknown | Unknown | Died in Civita Castellana |
| u1100–1101 | Theodoric | Unknown | Cava de' Tirreni | Died at La Trinità della Cava but buried in the local cemetery; tombstone contains the words "Theodoric, 1102" |
| v1101 | Adalbert | Unknown | Benedictine Abbey of San Lorenzo (Aversa) | |
| w1105–1111 | Sylvester IV | Unknown | Unknown | Died under the care of his patron, Count Werner of Ancona; nothing of death or burial known |
| x1118–1121 | Gregory VIII | Unknown | Unknown | Imprisoned in many places; last known to have been kept in Cava de' Tirreni, but it is unknown if he died there |
| y1124 | Celestine II | Unknown | Unknown | Not an antipope sensu stricto, because his election was legitimate; he was forced to resign a papacy a day after and subsequently submitted to the Pope Honorius II, who was elected in his place. Died from beating inflicted during the election. |
| z1130–1138 | Anacletus II | Unknown | Santa Maria in Trastevere | Destroyed by Pope Innocent II along with much of the church; Innocent II arranged for his own burial, in the rebuilt church, on the site of his former rivals' |
| za1138 | Victor IV | Unknown | Unknown(perhaps priorate of S. Eusebio in Fontanella) | Nothing known of his biography after his resignation |
| zb1159–1164 | Victor IV | Unknown | Monastery in Lucca | The clergy of the Lucca Cathedral and San Frediano would not allow him buried there because of his excommunication; tomb destroyed by Pope Gregory VIII in December 1187 |
| zc1164–1168 | Paschal III | Unknown | Unknown | Died in Castel Sant'Angelo |
| zd1168–1178 | Callixtus III | Unknown | Unknown | Died in Benevento |
| ze1179–1180 | Innocent III | Unknown | La Trinità della Cava (Cava de' Tirreni) | |
| zf1328–1330 | Nicholas V | Unknown | Avignon | Died in the Church of the Franciscans, Avignon |
| zg1378–1394 | Clement VII | Perrin Morel | Musée du Petit Palais, Avignon | Original canopied tomb in the Avignon Cathedral moved on September 8, 1401, to the chapel of the Celestines, and in 1658 to the choir of the church; almost completely destroyed during the French Revolution, only the head of the effigy remains |
| zh1394–1417 | Benedict XIII | Unknown | Castle of Illueca, Spain | Originally buried in the chapel crypt in Peñíscola; translated to Illueca, Spain and mummified under glass, attracting pilgrims; smashed by an Italian prelate Porro in 1537, after which the room was sealed by the archbishop of Saragossa; destroyed and desecrated by the French during the War of the Spanish Succession; skull recovered and put on display at the castle; buried in the palace of the Counts of Argillo y Morata at Sabinan in 1936 during the Spanish Civil War; skull stolen on August 23, 2000, by two brothers, who sent ransom notes to the Mayor of Illueca, Javier Vicente Inez; Spanish police recovered the skull and returned it to the Castle at Illueca on September 3, 2000 |
| zi1409–1410 | Alexander V | Niccolò di Piero Lamberti and Sperandio Savelli | San Francesco (Bologna) | Wall tomb |
| zj1410–1415 | John XXIII | Donatello and Michelozzo | Florence Baptistry | See Tomb of Antipope John XXIII |
| zk1423–1429 | Clement VIII | Unknown | La Seu (Mallorca) | Buried in the Cappella de la Piedad in the Cathedral of Palma, Spain |
| zl1424–1429 | Benedict XIV | None | Under a rock in Armagnac, France | Refused burial in a church because of his excommunication |
| zm1430–1437 | Benedict XIV | Unknown | Unknown | Died imprisoned in Château de Foix |
| zn1439–1449 | Felix VAmadeus VIII, Count of Savoy | Unknown | Hautecombe Abbey (Ripaille, France) | Destroyed during the French Revolution; name listed on an extant memorial plaque that commemorates him and the other Counts of Savoy, whose tombs were also destroyed in the same Abbey |