| Justice | State | Position | Succeeded | Date confirmed(Vote) | Tenure | Tenure length | Nominated by |
| No. | Portrait | Name(birth–death) |
| 1 | | John Jay(1745–1829) | NY | ChiefJustice | Inaugural | September 26, 1789(Acclamation) | October 19, 1789–June 29, 1795(Resigned) | 5 years, 253 days | George Washington |
| 2 | | John Rutledge(1739–1800) | SC | AssociateJustice | Inaugural | September 26, 1789(Acclamation) | February 15, 1790–March 5, 1791(Resigned) | 1 year, 18 days |
| 3 | | William Cushing(1732–1810) | MA | AssociateJustice | Inaugural | September 26, 1789(Acclamation) | February 2, 1790–September 13, 1810(Died) | 20 years, 223 days |
| 4 | | James Wilson(1742–1798) | PA | AssociateJustice | Inaugural | September 26, 1789(Acclamation) | October 5, 1789–August 21, 1798(Died) | 8 years, 320 days |
| 5 | | John Blair(1732–1800) | VA | AssociateJustice | Inaugural | September 26, 1789(Acclamation) | February 2, 1790–October 25, 1795(Resigned) | 5 years, 265 days |
| 6 | | James Iredell(1751–1799) | NC | AssociateJustice | Inaugural | February 10, 1790(Acclamation) | May 12, 1790–October 20, 1799(Died) | 9 years, 161 days |
| 7 | | Thomas Johnson(1732–1819) | MD | AssociateJustice | J. Rutledge | November 7, 1791(Acclamation) | September 19, 1791–January 16, 1793(Resigned) | 1 year, 119 days |
| 8 | | William Paterson(1745–1806) | NJ | AssociateJustice | T. Johnson | March 4, 1793(Acclamation) | March 11, 1793–September 9, 1806(Died) | 13 years, 181 days |
| 2 | | John Rutledge(1739–1800) | SC | ChiefJustice | Jay | December 15, 1795(10–14) | August 12, 1795–December 15, 1795(Resigned, nomination having been rejected) | 138 days |
| 9 | | Samuel Chase(1741–1811) | MD | AssociateJustice | Blair | January 27, 1796(Acclamation) | February 4, 1796–June 19, 1811(Died) | 15 years, 135 days |
| 10 | | Oliver Ellsworth(1745–1807) | CT | ChiefJustice | J. Rutledge | March 4, 1796(21–1) | March 8, 1796–December 15, 1800(Resigned) | 4 years, 282 days |
| 11 | | Bushrod Washington(1762–1829) | VA | AssociateJustice | Wilson | December 20, 1798(Acclamation) | November 9, 1798–November 26, 1829(Died) | 31 years, 17 days | John Adams |
| 12 | | Alfred Moore(1755–1810) | NC | AssociateJustice | Iredell | December 9, 1799(Acclamation) | April 21, 1800–January 26, 1804(Resigned) | 3 years, 280 days |
| 13 | | John Marshall(1755–1835) | VA | ChiefJustice | Ellsworth | January 27, 1801(Acclamation) | February 4, 1801–July 6, 1835(Died) | 34 years, 152 days |
| 14 | | William Johnson(1771–1834) | SC | AssociateJustice | Moore | March 24, 1804(Acclamation) | May 7, 1804–August 4, 1834(Died) | 30 years, 89 days | Thomas Jefferson |
| 15 | | Henry Brockholst Livingston(1757–1823) | NY | AssociateJustice | Paterson | December 17, 1806(Acclamation) | January 20, 1807–March 18, 1823(Died) | 16 years, 57 days |
| 16 | | Thomas Todd(1765–1826) | KY | AssociateJustice | new seat | March 2, 1807(Acclamation) | May 4, 1807–February 7, 1826(Died) | 18 years, 341 days |
| 17 | | Gabriel Duvall(1752–1844) | MD | AssociateJustice | S. Chase | November 18, 1811(Acclamation) | November 23, 1811–January 14, 1835(Resigned) | 23 years, 50 days | James Madison |
| 18 | | Joseph Story(1779–1845) | MA | AssociateJustice | Cushing | November 18, 1811(Acclamation) | February 3, 1812–September 10, 1845(Died) | 33 years, 219 days |
| 19 | | Smith Thompson(1768–1843) | NY | AssociateJustice | Livingston | December 9, 1823(Acclamation) | September 1, 1823–December 18, 1843(Died) | 20 years, 108 days | James Monroe |
| 20 | | Robert Trimble(1776–1828) | KY | AssociateJustice | Todd | May 9, 1826(25–5) | June 16, 1826–August 25, 1828(Died) | 2 years, 70 days | John Quincy Adams |
| 21 | | John McLean(1785–1861) | OH | AssociateJustice | Trimble | March 7, 1829(Acclamation) | March 12, 1829–April 4, 1861(Died) | 32 years, 23 days | Andrew Jackson |
| 22 | | Henry Baldwin(1780–1844) | PA | AssociateJustice | Washington | January 6, 1830(41–2) | January 18, 1830–April 21, 1844(Died) | 14 years, 94 days |
| 23 | | James Moore Wayne(1790–1867) | GA | AssociateJustice | W. Johnson | January 9, 1835(Acclamation) | January 14, 1835–July 5, 1867(Died) | 32 years, 172 days |
| 24 | | Roger B. Taney(1777–1864) | MD | ChiefJustice | J. Marshall | March 15, 1836(29–15) | March 28, 1836–October 12, 1864(Died) | 28 years, 198 days |
| 25 | | Philip P. Barbour(1783–1841) | VA | AssociateJustice | Duvall | March 15, 1836(30–11) | May 12, 1836–February 25, 1841(Died) | 4 years, 289 days |
| 26 | | John Catron(1786–1865) | TN | AssociateJustice | new seat | March 8, 1837(28–15) | May 1, 1837–May 30, 1865(Died) | 28 years, 29 days |
| 27 | | John McKinley(1780–1852) | AL | AssociateJustice | new seat | September 25, 1837(Acclamation) | January 9, 1838–July 19, 1852(Died) | 14 years, 192 days | Martin Van Buren |
| 28 | | Peter Vivian Daniel(1784–1860) | VA | AssociateJustice | Barbour | March 2, 1841(25–5) | January 10, 1842–May 31, 1860(Died) | 18 years, 142 days |
| 29 | | Samuel Nelson(1792–1873) | NY | AssociateJustice | Thompson | February 14, 1845(Acclamation) | February 27, 1845–November 28, 1872(Retired) | 27 years, 275 days | John Tyler |
| 30 | | Levi Woodbury(1789–1851) | NH | AssociateJustice | Story | January 31, 1846(Acclamation) | September 23, 1845–September 4, 1851(Died) | 5 years, 346 days | James K. Polk |
| 31 | | Robert Cooper Grier(1794–1870) | PA | AssociateJustice | Baldwin | August 4, 1846(Acclamation) | August 10, 1846–January 31, 1870(Retired) | 23 years, 174 days |
| 32 | | Benjamin Robbins Curtis(1809–1874) | MA | AssociateJustice | Woodbury | December 20, 1851(Acclamation) | October 10, 1851–September 30, 1857(Resigned) | 5 years, 355 days | Millard Fillmore |
| 33 | | John Archibald Campbell(1811–1889) | AL | AssociateJustice | McKinley | March 22, 1853(Acclamation) | April 11, 1853–April 30, 1861(Resigned) | 8 years, 19 days | Franklin Pierce |
| 34 | | Nathan Clifford(1803–1881) | ME | AssociateJustice | Curtis | January 12, 1858(26–23) | January 21, 1858–July 25, 1881(Died) | 23 years, 185 days | James Buchanan |
| 35 | | Noah Haynes Swayne(1804–1884) | OH | AssociateJustice | McLean | January 24, 1862(38–1) | January 27, 1862–January 24, 1881(Retired) | 18 years, 363 days | Abraham Lincoln |
| 36 | | Samuel Freeman Miller(1816–1890) | IA | AssociateJustice | Daniel | July 16, 1862(Acclamation) | July 21, 1862–October 13, 1890(Died) | 28 years, 84 days |
| 37 | | David Davis(1815–1886) | IL | AssociateJustice | Campbell | December 8, 1862(Acclamation) | December 10, 1862–March 4, 1877(Resigned) | 14 years, 84 days |
| 38 | | Stephen Johnson Field(1816–1899) | CA | AssociateJustice | new seat | March 10, 1863(Acclamation) | May 20, 1863–December 1, 1897(Retired) | 34 years, 195 days |
| 39 | | Salmon P. Chase(1808–1873) | OH | ChiefJustice | Taney | December 6, 1864(Acclamation) | December 15, 1864–May 7, 1873(Died) | 8 years, 143 days |
| 40 | | William Strong(1808–1895) | PA | AssociateJustice | Grier | February 18, 1870(No vote recorded) | March 14, 1870–December 14, 1880(Retired) | 10 years, 275 days | Ulysses S. Grant |
| 41 | | Joseph P. Bradley(1813–1892) | NJ | AssociateJustice | new seat | March 21, 1870(46–9) | March 23, 1870–January 22, 1892(Died) | 21 years, 305 days |
| 42 | | Ward Hunt(1810–1886) | NY | AssociateJustice | Nelson | December 11, 1872(Acclamation) | January 9, 1873–January 27, 1882(Retired) | 9 years, 18 days |
| 43 | | Morrison Waite(1816–1888) | OH | ChiefJustice | S. P. Chase | January 21, 1874(63–0) | March 4, 1874–March 23, 1888(Died) | 14 years, 19 days |
| 44 | | John Marshall Harlan(1833–1911) | KY | AssociateJustice | Davis | November 29, 1877(Acclamation) | December 10, 1877–October 14, 1911(Died) | 33 years, 308 days | Rutherford B. Hayes |
| 45 | | William Burnham Woods(1824–1887) | GA | AssociateJustice | Strong | December 21, 1880(39–8) | January 5, 1881–May 14, 1887(Died) | 6 years, 129 days |
| 46 | | Stanley Matthews(1824–1889) | OH | AssociateJustice | Swayne | May 12, 1881(24–23) | May 17, 1881–March 22, 1889(Died) | 7 years, 309 days | James A. Garfield |
| 47 | | Horace Gray(1828–1902) | MA | AssociateJustice | Clifford | December 20, 1881(51–5) | January 9, 1882–September 15, 1902(Died) | 20 years, 249 days | Chester A. Arthur |