| Goals scored | Date | Home team | Result | Away team | Goalscorers | Ref. |
| 11 | 29 September 2007 | Portsmouth | 7–4 | Reading | Benjani 6', 37', 70', Hreiðarsson 55', Kranjčar 75', Ingimarsson 81' (o.g.), Muntari 90+2' (pen.) Hunt 45', Kitson 48', Long 79', Campbell 90+4' (o.g.) | |
| 10 | 29 December 2007 | Tottenham Hotspur | 6–4 | Reading | Berbatov 7', 63', 73', 83', Malbranque 76', Defoe 79' Cissé 16', Ingimarsson 53', Kitson 69', 74' | |
| 10 | 22 November 2009 | Tottenham Hotspur | 9–1 | Wigan Athletic | Crouch 9', Defoe 51', 54', 58', 69', 87', Lennon 64', Bentley 88', Kranjčar 90' Scharner 57' | |
| 10 | 28 August 2011 | Manchester United | 8–2 | Arsenal | Welbeck 22', Young 28', 90+1', Rooney 41', 64', 82' (pen.), Nani 67', Park 70' Walcott 45+3', Van Persie 74' | |
| 10 | 29 December 2012 | Arsenal | 7–3 | Newcastle United | Walcott 20', 73', 90+2', Oxlade-Chamberlain 50', Podolski 64', Giroud 84', 87' Ba 43', 69', Marveaux 59' | |
| 10 | 19 May 2013 | West Bromwich Albion | 5–5 | Manchester United | Morrison 40', Lukaku 50', 81', 86', Mulumbu 81' Kagawa 6', Olsson 9' (o.g.), Büttner 30', Van Persie 53', Hernández 63' | |
| 9 | 9 April 1994 | Norwich City | 4–5 | Southampton | Robins 37', Goss 49', Sutton 56', 64' Ullathorne 44' (o.g.), Le Tissier 58', 63' (pen.), 73', Monkou 90' | |
| 9 | 4 March 1995 | Manchester United | 9–0 | Ipswich Town | Keane 15', Cole 19', 37', 53', 65', 87', Hughes 55', 59', Ince 72' – | |
| 9 | 26 October 1996 | Southampton | 6–3 | Manchester United | Berkovic 6', 63', Le Tissier 34', Østenstad 45', 85', P.Neville 90' (o.g.) Beckham 41', May 56', Scholes 89' | |
| 9 | 26 August 1997 | Blackburn Rovers | 7–2 | Sheffield Wednesday | Gallacher 2', 7', Hyde 10' (o.g.), Wilcox 20', Sutton 24', 74', Bohinen 53' Carbone 8', 47' | |
| 9 | 6 February 1999 | Nottingham Forest | 1–8 | Manchester United | Rogers 6' Yorke 2', 67', Cole 7', 50', Solskjær 80', 88', 90', 90+1' | |
| 9 | 12 February 2000 | West Ham United | 5–4 | Bradford City | Sinclair 35', Moncur 43', Di Canio 65' (pen.), Cole 70', Lampard 83' Windass 30', Beagrie 44' (pen.), Lawrence 47', 51' | |
| 9 | 11 March 2000 | Tottenham Hotspur | 7–2 | Southampton | Richards 28' (o.g.), Anderton 39', Armstrong 41', 64', Iversen 45', 78', 90' Tessem 26', El Khalej 33' | |
| 9 | 13 November 2004 | Tottenham Hotspur | 4–5 | Arsenal | Naybet 37', Defoe 61', King 74', Kanouté 88' Henry 45', Lauren 55' (pen.), Vieira 60', Ljungberg 69', Pires 81' | |
| 9 | 11 May 2008 | Middlesbrough | 8–1 | Manchester City | Downing 16' (pen.), 58' Alves 37', 60', 90', Johnson 70', Rochemback 80', Aliadière 85' Elano 87' | |
| 9 | 16 January 2010 | Chelsea | 7–2 | Sunderland | Anelka 8', 65', Malouda 17', A.Cole 22', Lampard 34', 90', Ballack 52' Zenden 56', Bent 90' | |
| 9 | 14 December 2013 | Manchester City | 6–3 | Arsenal | Agüero 14', Negredo 39', Fernandinho 50', 88', D.Silva 66', Touré 90' (pen.) Walcott 31', 63', Mertesacker 90' | |
| 9 | 22 March 2014 | Cardiff City | 3–6 | Liverpool | Mutch 9', 88', Campbell 25' Suárez 16', 60', 90', Škrtel 41', 54', Sturridge 75' | |
| 9 | 30 August 2014 | Everton | 3–6 | Chelsea | Mirallas 45', Naismith 69', Eto'o 76' Costa 1', 90', Ivanović 3', Coleman 67' (o.g.), Matić 74', Ramires 77' | |
| 9 | 23 January 2016 | Norwich City | 4–5 | Liverpool | Mbokani 29', Naismith 41', Hoolahan 54' (pen.), Bassong 90+2' Firmino 18', 63', Henderson 55', Milner 75', Lallana 90+5' | |
| 9 | 26 November 2016 | Swansea City | 5–4 | Crystal Palace | Sigurðsson 36', Fer 66', 68', Llorente 90+1', 90+3' Zaha 19', Tomkins 75', Cork 82' (o.g.), C.Benteke 84' | |
| 9 | 4 February 2017 | Everton | 6–3 | Bournemouth | Lukaku 1', 29', 83', 84', McCarthy 24', Barkley 90+4' King 59', 70', Arter 90' | |
| 9 | 14 October 2017 | Manchester City | 7–2 | Stoke City | Gabriel Jesus 17', 55', Sterling 19', D.Silva 27', Fernandinho 60', Sané 62', B.Silva 79' Diouf 44', Walker 47' (o.g.) | |
| 9 | 13 May 2018 | Tottenham Hotspur | 5–4 | Leicester City | Kane 7', 76', Lamela 49', 60', Fuchs 53' (o.g.) Vardy 4', 73', Mahrez 16', Iheanacho 47' | |
| 9 | 25 October 2019 | Southampton | 0–9 | Leicester City | – Chilwell 10', Tielemans 17', Pérez 19', 39', 57', Vardy 45', 58', 90+4' (pen.), Maddison 85' | |
| 9 | 4 October 2020 | Aston Villa | 7–2 | Liverpool | Watkins 4', 22', 39', McGinn 35', Barkley 55', Grealish 66', 75' Salah 33', 60' | |
| 9 | 2 February 2021 | Manchester United | 9–0 | Southampton | Wan-Bissaka 18', Rashford 25', Bednarek 34' (o.g.), Cavani 39', Martial 69', 90', McTominay 71', Fernandes 88' (pen.), James 90+3' – | |
| 9 | 26 December 2021 | Manchester City | 6–3 | Leicester City | De Bruyne 5', Mahrez 14' (pen.), Gündoğan 21', Sterling 25' (pen.), 85', Laporte 69' Maddison 55', Lookman 59', Iheanacho 65' | |
| 9 | 27 August 2022 | Liverpool | 9–0 | Bournemouth | Díaz 3', 85', Elliott 6', Alexander-Arnold 28', Firmino 31', 62', Van Dijk 45', Mepham 46' (o.g.), Carvalho 80' – | |
| 9 | 2 October 2022 | Manchester City | 6–3 | Manchester United | Foden 8', 44', 73', Haaland 34', 37', 64' Antony 56', Martial 84', 90+1' (pen.) | |
| 9 | 22 December 2024 | Tottenham Hotspur | 3–6 | Liverpool | Maddison 41', Kulusevski 72', Solanke 83' Díaz 23', 85', Mac Allister 36', Szoboszlai 45+1', Salah 54', 61' | |
| 9 | 2 December 2025 | Fulham | 4–5 | Manchester City | Smith Rowe 45+2', Iwobi 57', Chukwueze 72', 78' Haaland 17', Reijnders 37', Foden 44', 48', Berge 54' (o.g.) | |
