| No. | Portrait | Name(Birth–Death) | Elected | Term of office | Party | Title(s) |
| Took office | Left office | Time in office |
| 10 | | Fabre Geffrard(1806–1878) | — | 15 January 1859 | 13 March 1867 | 8 years, 57 days | Independent | President |
| — | | Jean-Nicolas Nissage Saget(1810–1880) | — | 13 March 1867 | 4 May 1867 | 52 days | Independent | Provisional President |
| 11 | | Sylvain Salnave(1827–1870) | — | 4 May 1867 | 27 December 1869 | 2 years, 237 days | Independent | President |
| 12 | | Jean-Nicolas Nissage Saget(1810–1880) | — | 27 December 1869 | 14 May 1874 | 4 years, 138 days | Liberal Party | President |
| — | | Council of Secretaries of State | — | 14 May 1874 | 14 June 1874 | 31 days | Independent | Council of Secretaries of State |
| 13 | | Michel Domingue(1813–1877) | — | 14 June 1874 | 15 April 1876 | 1 year, 306 days | National Party | President |
| 14 | | Pierre Théoma Boisrond-Canal(1832–1905) | — | 23 April 1876 | 17 July 1879 | 3 years, 85 days | Liberal Party | Provisional President (23 April 1876 – 17 July 1876)President (17 July 1876 – 17 July 1879) |
| — | | Public Order Committee | — | 17 July 1879 | 26 July 1879 | 9 days | Independent | |
| — | | Joseph Lamothe(?–1891) | — | 26 July 1879 | 3 October 1879 | 69 days | Independent | Provisional President |
| — | | Florvil Hyppolite(1828–1896) | — | 3 October 1879 | 26 October 1879 | 23 days | National Party | Provisional President |
| 15 | | Lysius Salomon(1815–1888) | — | 26 October 1879 | 10 August 1888 | 8 years, 289 days | National Party | President |
| — | | Pierre Théoma Boisrond-Canal(1832–1905) | — | 10 August 1888 | 16 October 1888 | 67 days | Liberal Party | Provisional President |
| 16 | | François Denys Légitime(1841–1935) | — | 16 October 1888 | 23 August 1889 | 311 days | Liberal Party | President |
| — | | Monpoint Jeune(1830–1905) | — | 23 August 1889 | 17 October 1889 | 55 days | Independent | Provisional President |
| 17 | | Florvil Hyppolite(1828–1896) | — | 17 October 1889 | 24 March 1896 | 6 years, 159 days | National Party | President |
| 18 | | Tirésias Simon Sam(1835–1916) | — | 31 March 1896 | 12 May 1902 | 6 years, 42 days | National Party | President |
| — | | Pierre Théoma Boisrond-Canal(1832–1905) | — | 14 May 1902 | 17 December 1902 | 217 days | Liberal Party | President of the Committee of Public Safety (14 May 1902 – 26 May 1902)Provisional President (26 May 1902 – 17 December 1902) |
| 19 | | Pierre Nord Alexis(1820–1910) | — | 17 December 1902 | 2 December 1908 | 5 years, 351 days | Military | President |
| — | | Commission for Public Order | — | 2 December 1908 | 6 December 1908 | 4 days | Independent | |
| 20 | | François C. Antoine Simon(1843–1923) | — | 6 December 1908 | 2 August 1911 | 2 years, 239 days | Liberal Party | President |
| 21 | | Cincinnatus Leconte(1854–1912) | — | 15 August 1911 | 8 August 1912 | 359 days | National Party | President |
| 22 | | Tancrède Auguste(1856–1913) | — | 8 August 1912 | 2 May 1913 | 267 days | National Party | President |
| 23 | | Michel Oreste(1859–1918) | — | 12 May 1913 | 27 January 1914 | 260 days | Independent | President |
| — | | Edmond Polynice(1855–1915) | — | 27 January 1914 | 8 February 1914 | 12 days | Military | Provisional President |
| 24 | | Oreste Zamor(1861–1915) | — | 8 February 1914 | 29 October 1914 | 263 days | Military | President |
| — | | Edmond Polynice(1855–1915) | — | 29 October 1914 | 6 November 1914 | 8 days | Military | Provisional President |
| 25 | | Joseph Davilmar Théodore(1847–1917) | — | 7 November 1914 | 22 February 1915 | 107 days | Military | President |
| 26 | | Vilbrun Guillaume Sam(1859–1915) | — | 25 February 1915 | 28 July 1915 | 153 days | Military | President |
| — | | Revolutionary Committee | — | 28 July 1915 | 11 August 1915 | 14 days | Independent | |
| 27 | | Philippe Sudré Dartiguenave(1863–1926) | — | 12 August 1915 | 15 May 1922 | 6 years, 276 days | Independent | President |
| 28 | | Louis Borno(1865–1942) | — | 15 May 1922 | 15 May 1930 | 8 years | Independent | President |
| 29 | | Louis Eugène Roy(1861–1939) | — | 15 May 1930 | 18 November 1930 | 187 days | Independent | President |
| 30 | | Sténio Vincent(1874–1959) | — | 18 November 1930 | 15 May 1941 | 10 years, 178 days | Independent | President |
| 31 | | Élie Lescot(1883–1974) | — | 15 May 1941 | 11 January 1946 | 4 years, 241 days | Liberal Party | President |
| 32 | | Franck Lavaud(1903–1986) | — | 11 January 1946 | 16 August 1946 | 217 days | Military | Chairman of the Military Executive Committee |
| 33 | | Dumarsais Estimé(1900–1953) | 1946 | 16 August 1946 | 10 May 1950 | 3 years, 267 days | Liberal Party | President |
| 34 | | Franck Lavaud(1903–1986) | — | 10 May 1950 | 6 December 1950 | 210 days | Military | Chairman of the Government Junta |
| 35 | | Paul Magloire(1907–2001) | 1950 | 6 December 1950 | 12 December 1956 | 6 years, 6 days | Peasant Worker Movement | President |
| 36 | | Joseph Nemours Pierre-Louis(1900–1966) | — | 12 December 1956 | 3 February 1957 | 53 days | Independent | Provisional President |
| 37 | | Franck Sylvain(1909–1987) | — | 7 February 1957 | 2 April 1957 | 54 days | Independent | Provisional President |
| — | | Léon Cantave(1910–1967) | — | 2 April 1957 | 6 April 1957 | 4 days | Military | Acting President |
| — | | Executive Government Council | — | 6 April 1957 | 20 May 1957 | 44 days | Independent | Executive Government Council |
| — | | Léon Cantave(1910–1967) | — | 20 May 1957 | 25 May 1957 | 5 days | Military | Acting President |
| — | | Daniel Fignolé(1913–1986) | — | 25 May 1957 | 14 June 1957 | 20 days | Peasant Worker Movement | Provisional President |
| 38 | | Antonio Thrasybule Kébreau(1909–1963) | — | 14 June 1957 | 22 October 1957 | 130 days | Military | Chairman of the Military Council |