| Year | Category | Nominee | Result | Ref |
| 2016 | Best Comedy Series | Eugene Levy, Daniel Levy, Andrew Barnsley, Fred Levy, Ben Feigin, Mike Short, Kevin White and Colin Brunton | Won | |
| Best Performance by an Actor in a Continuing Leading Comedic Role | Daniel Levy (for "The Cabin") | Nominated |
| Eugene Levy (for "Carl's Funeral") | Won |
| Best Performance by an Actress in a Continuing Leading Comedic Role | Annie Murphy (for "The Cabin") | Nominated |
| Catherine O'Hara (for "Don't Worry, It's His Sister") | Won |
| Best Performance by an Actor in a Featured Supporting Role or Guest Role in a Comedic Series | Chris Elliott (for "Honeymoon" and "Surprise Party") | Won |
| Best Performance by an Actress in a Featured Supporting Role or Guest Role in a Comedic Series | Emily Hampshire (for "Our Cup Runneth Over" and "Carl's Funeral") | Won |
| Jennifer Robertson (for "Turkey Shoot" and "Honeymoon") | Nominated |
| Best Direction in a Comedy Program | Jerry Ciccoritti (for "Our Cup Runneth Over") | Nominated |
| Paul Fox (for "The Cabin") | Won |
| Best Writing in a Comedy Program or Series | Daniel Levy (for "Honeymoon") | Won |
| Mike Short (for "Don't Worry, It's His Sister") | Nominated |
| Best Picture Editing in a Comedy Program or Series | James Bredin (for "Surprise Party") | Won |
| Best Photography in a Comedy Program or Series | Gerald Packer (for "Honeymoon") | Won |
| Best Cross-Platform Project, Fiction | Cory Lawrence, Eugene Levy, Daniel Levy, Andrew Barnsley, Fred Levy, Ben Feigin and Colin Brunton (for Schitt's Creek Webisodes) | Nominated |
| 2017 | Best Comedy Series | Eugene Levy, Daniel Levy, Andrew Barnsley, Fred Levy, Kevin White, Mike Short, Colin Brunton and Ben Feigin | Nominated | |
| Best Performance by an Actor in a Continuing Leading Comedic Role | Daniel Levy | Nominated |
| Eugene Levy | Nominated |
| Best Performance by an Actress in a Continuing Leading Comedic Role | Catherine O'Hara | Won |
| Best Performance by an Actor in a Featured Supporting Role or Guest Role in a Comedic Series | John Hemphill (for "Bob's Bagels") | Nominated |
| Best Performance by an Actress in a Featured Supporting Role or Guest Role in a Comedic Series | Emily Hampshire (for "Bob's Bagels" and "Moira's Nudes") | Won |
| Best Direction in a Comedy Program or Series | Jerry Ciccoritti (for "Moira's Nudes") | Nominated |
| Paul Fox (for "Happy Anniversary") | Nominated |
| Best Achievement in Casting | Lisa Parasyn and Jon Comerford (for "Bob's Bagels") | Nominated |
| Best Photography in a Comedy Program or Series | Gerald Packer (for "Finding David") | Nominated |
| Gerald Packer (for "Happy Anniversary") | Nominated |
| Best Picture Editing in a Comedy Program or Series | Trevor Ambrose (for "Happy Anniversary") | Nominated |
| Trevor Ambrose (for "Moira's Nudes") | Nominated |
| 2018 | Best Lead Actor, Comedy | Daniel Levy | Nominated | |
| Eugene Levy | Nominated |
| Best Lead Actress, Comedy | Annie Murphy | Nominated |
| Catherine O'Hara | Won |
| Best Supporting or Guest Actor, Comedy | Noah Reid (for "Grad Night" and "Bad Review") | Nominated |
| Best Supporting or Guest Actress, Comedy | Emily Hampshire (for "New Car" and "The Throuple") | Won |
| Jennifer Robertson (for "The Affair" and "General Store") | Nominated |
| Best Direction, Comedy | Paul Fox (for "New Car") | Nominated |
| T. W. Peacocke (for "Grad Night") | Nominated |
| Best Writing, Comedy | Daniel Levy (for "Opening Night") | Nominated |
| Best Photography, Comedy | Gerald Packer (for "Grad Night") | Won |
| 2019 | Best Comedy Series | Eugene Levy, Daniel Levy, Andrew Barnsley, Fred Levy and Ben Feigin | Won | |
| Best Lead Actor, Comedy | Daniel Levy | Nominated |
| Eugene Levy | Nominated |
| Best Lead Actress, Comedy | Annie Murphy | Nominated |
| Catherine O'Hara | Won |
| Best Supporting or Guest Actor, Comedy | Chris Elliott (for "RIP Moira Rose" and "Girls' Night") | Nominated |
| Noah Reid (for "Open Mic" and "The Barbecue") | Won |
| Best Supporting or Guest Actress, Comedy | Emily Hampshire (for "The Olive Branch" and "The Jazzaguy") | Won |
| Jennifer Robertson (for "Baby Sprinkle" and "Singles Week") | Nominated |
| Best Direction, Comedy | Daniel Levy and Andrew Cividino (for "Merry Christmas, Johnny Rose") | Nominated |
