| Game | Date (Season) | Winning team | Score | Losing team | Venue | City | Attendance | Referee | Ref. |
| I | January 15, 1967 (1966 AFL/1966 NFL) | Green Bay Packersn(1, 1–0) | 35–10 | Kansas City Chiefsa(1, 0–1) | Los Angeles Memorial Coliseum | Los Angeles, California | 61,946 | Norm Schachter | |
| II | January 14, 1968 (1967 AFL/1967 NFL) | Green Bay Packersn(2, 2–0) | 33–14 | Oakland Raidersa(1, 0–1) | Miami Orange Bowl | Miami, Florida | 75,546 | Jack Vest | |
| III | January 12, 1969 (1968 AFL/1968 NFL) | New York Jetsa(1, 1–0) | 16–7 | Baltimore Coltsn(1, 0–1) | Miami Orange Bowl (2) | Miami, Florida (2) | 75,389 | Tom Bell | |
| IV | January 11, 1970 (1969 AFL/1969 NFL) | Kansas City Chiefsa(2, 1–1) | 23–7 | Minnesota Vikingsn(1, 0–1) | Tulane Stadium | New Orleans, Louisiana | 80,562 | John McDonough | |
| V | January 17, 1971 (1970) | Baltimore ColtsA(2, 1–1) | 16–13 | Dallas CowboysN(1, 0–1) | Miami Orange Bowl (3) | Miami, Florida (3) | 79,204 | Norm Schachter | |
| VI | January 16, 1972 (1971) | Dallas CowboysN(2, 1–1) | 24–3 | Miami DolphinsA(1, 0–1) | Tulane Stadium (2) | New Orleans, Louisiana (2) | 81,023 | Jim Tunney | |
| VII | January 14, 1973 (1972) | Miami DolphinsA(2, 1–1) | 14–7 | Washington RedskinsN(1, 0–1) | Los Angeles Memorial Coliseum (2) | Los Angeles, California (2) | 90,182 | Tom Bell | |
| VIII | January 13, 1974 (1973) | Miami DolphinsA(3, 2–1) | 24–7 | Minnesota VikingsN(2, 0–2) | Rice Stadium | Houston, Texas | 71,882 | Ben Dreith | |
| IX | January 12, 1975 (1974) | Pittsburgh SteelersA(1, 1–0) | 16–6 | Minnesota VikingsN(3, 0–3) | Tulane Stadium (3) | New Orleans, Louisiana (3) | 80,997 | Bernie Ulman | |
| X | January 18, 1976 (1975) | Pittsburgh SteelersA(2, 2–0) | 21–17 | Dallas CowboysN(3, 1–2) .mw- [W] | Miami Orange Bowl (4) | Miami, Florida (4) | 80,187 | Norm Schachter | |
| XI | January 9, 1977 (1976) | Oakland RaidersA(2, 1–1) | 32–14 | Minnesota VikingsN(4, 0–4) | Rose Bowl | Pasadena, California (3) | 103,438 | Jim Tunney | |
| XII | January 15, 1978 (1977) | Dallas CowboysN(4, 2–2) | 27–10 | Denver BroncosA(1, 0–1) | Louisiana Superdome | New Orleans, Louisiana (4) | 76,400 | Jim Tunney | |
| XIII | January 21, 1979 (1978) | Pittsburgh SteelersA(3, 3–0) | 35–31 | Dallas CowboysN(5, 2–3) | Miami Orange Bowl (5) | Miami, Florida (5) | 79,484 | Pat Haggerty | |
| XIV | January 20, 1980 (1979) | Pittsburgh SteelersA(4, 4–0) | 31–19 | Los Angeles RamsN(1, 0–1) | Rose Bowl (2) | Pasadena, California (4) | 103,985 | Fred Silva | |
| XV | January 25, 1981 (1980) | Oakland RaidersA(3, 2–1) [W] | 27–10 | Philadelphia EaglesN(1, 0–1) | Louisiana Superdome (2) | New Orleans, Louisiana (5) | 76,135 | Ben Dreith | |
| XVI | January 24, 1982 (1981) | San Francisco 49ersN(1, 1–0) | 26–21 | Cincinnati BengalsA(1, 0–1) | Pontiac Silverdome | Pontiac, Michigan | 81,270 | Pat Haggerty | |
| XVII | January 30, 1983 (1982) | Washington RedskinsN(2, 1–1) | 27–17 | Miami DolphinsA(4, 2–2) | Rose Bowl (3) | Pasadena, California (5) | 103,667 | Jerry Markbreit | |
| XVIII | January 22, 1984 (1983) | Los Angeles RaidersA(4, 3–1) | 38–9 | Washington RedskinsN(3, 1–2) | Tampa Stadium | Tampa, Florida | 72,920 | Gene Barth | |
| XIX | January 20, 1985 (1984) | San Francisco 49ersN(2, 2–0) | 38–16 | Miami DolphinsA(5, 2–3) | Stanford Stadium | Stanford, California | 84,059 | Pat Haggerty | |
| XX | January 26, 1986 (1985) | Chicago BearsN(1, 1–0) | 46–10 | New England PatriotsA(1, 0–1) [W] | Louisiana Superdome (3) | New Orleans, Louisiana (6) | 73,818 | Red Cashion | |
| XXI | January 25, 1987 (1986) | New York GiantsN(1, 1–0) | 39–20 | Denver BroncosA(2, 0–2) | Rose Bowl (4) | Pasadena, California (6) | 101,063 | Jerry Markbreit | |
| XXII | January 31, 1988 (1987) | Washington RedskinsN(4, 2–2) | 42–10 | Denver BroncosA(3, 0–3) | San Diego–Jack Murphy Stadium | San Diego, California | 73,302 | Bob McElwee | |
| XXIII | January 22, 1989 (1988) | San Francisco 49ersN(3, 3–0) | 20–16 | Cincinnati BengalsA(2, 0–2) | Joe Robbie Stadium | Miami, Florida (6) | 75,129 | Jerry Seeman | |
| XXIV | January 28, 1990 (1989) | San Francisco 49ersN(4, 4–0) | 55–10 | Denver BroncosA(4, 0–4) | Louisiana Superdome (4) | New Orleans, Louisiana (7) | 72,919 | Dick Jorgensen | |
| XXV | January 27, 1991 (1990) | New York GiantsN(2, 2–0) | 20–19 | Buffalo BillsA(1, 0–1) | Tampa Stadium (2) | Tampa, Florida (2) | 73,813 | Jerry Seeman | |
| XXVI | January 26, 1992 (1991) | Washington RedskinsN(5, 3–2) | 37–24 | Buffalo BillsA(2, 0–2) | Metrodome | Minneapolis, Minnesota | 63,130 | Jerry Markbreit | |
| XXVII | January 31, 1993 (1992) | Dallas CowboysN(6, 3–3) | 52–17 | Buffalo BillsA(3, 0–3) [W] | Rose Bowl (5) | Pasadena, California (7) | 98,374 | Dick Hantak | |
| XXVIII | January 30, 1994 (1993) | Dallas CowboysN(7, 4–3) | 30–13 | Buffalo BillsA(4, 0–4) | Georgia Dome | Atlanta, Georgia | 72,817 | Bob McElwee | |
| XXIX | January 29, 1995 (1994) | San Francisco 49ersN(5, 5–0) | 49–26 | San Diego ChargersA(1, 0–1) | Joe Robbie Stadium (2) | Miami, Florida (7) | 74,107 | Jerry Markbreit | |
| XXX | January 28, 1996 (1995) | Dallas CowboysN(8, 5–3) | 27–17 | Pittsburgh SteelersA(5, 4–1) | Sun Devil Stadium | Tempe, Arizona | 76,347 | Red Cashion | |
| XXXI | January 26, 1997 (1996) | Green Bay PackersN(3, 3–0) | 35–21 | New England PatriotsA(2, 0–2) | Louisiana Superdome (5) | New Orleans, Louisiana (8) | 72,301 | Gerry Austin | |
| XXXII | January 25, 1998 (1997) | Denver BroncosA(5, 1–4)[W] | 31–24 | Green Bay PackersN(4, 3–1) | Qualcomm Stadium (2) | San Diego, California (2) | 68,912 | Ed Hochuli | |
| XXXIII | January 31, 1999 (1998) | Denver BroncosA(6, 2–4) | 34–19 | Atlanta FalconsN(1, 0–1) | Pro Player Stadium (3) | Miami, Florida (8) | 74,803 | Bernie Kukar | |
| XXXIV | January 30, 2000 (1999) | St. Louis RamsN(2, 1–1) | 23–16 | Tennessee TitansA(1, 0–1) [W] | Georgia Dome (2) | Atlanta, Georgia (2) | 72,625 | Bob McElwee | |
| XXXV | January 28, 2001 (2000) | Baltimore RavensA(1, 1–0) [W] | 34–7 | New York GiantsN(3, 2–1) | Raymond James Stadium | Tampa, Florida (3) | 71,921 | Gerry Austin | |
| XXXVI | February 3, 2002 (2001) | New England PatriotsA(3, 1–2) | 20–17 | St. Louis RamsN(3, 1–2) | Louisiana Superdome (6) | New Orleans, Louisiana (9) | 72,922 | Bernie Kukar | |
| XXXVII | January 26, 2003 (2002) | Tampa Bay BuccaneersN(1, 1–0) | 48–21 | Oakland RaidersA(5, 3–2) | Qualcomm Stadium (3) | San Diego, California (3) | 67,603 | Bill Carollo | |
| XXXVIII | February 1, 2004 (2003) | New England PatriotsA(4, 2–2) | 32–29 | Carolina PanthersN(1, 0–1) | Reliant Stadium | Houston, Texas (2) | 71,525 | Ed Hochuli | |
| XXXIX | February 6, 2005 (2004) | New England PatriotsA(5, 3–2) | 24–21 | Philadelphia EaglesN(2, 0–2) | Alltel Stadium | Jacksonville, Florida | 78,125 | Terry McAulay | |
| XL | February 5, 2006 (2005) | Pittsburgh SteelersA(6, 5–1) [W] | 21–10 | Seattle SeahawksN(1, 0–1) | Ford Field | Detroit, Michigan (2) | 68,206 | Bill Leavy | |
| XLI | February 4, 2007 (2006) | Indianapolis ColtsA(3, 2–1) | 29–17 | Chicago BearsN(2, 1–1) | Dolphin Stadium (4) | Miami Gardens, Florida (9) | 74,512 | Tony Corrente | |
| XLII | February 3, 2008 (2007) | New York GiantsN(4, 3–1) [W] | 17–14 | New England PatriotsA(6, 3–3) | University of Phoenix Stadium | Glendale, Arizona (2) | 71,101 | Mike Carey | |
| XLIII | February 1, 2009 (2008) | Pittsburgh SteelersA(7, 6–1) | 27–23 | Arizona CardinalsN(1, 0–1) | Raymond James Stadium (2) | Tampa, Florida (4) | 70,774 | Terry McAulay | |
| XLIV | February 7, 2010 (2009) | New Orleans SaintsN(1, 1–0) | 31–17 | Indianapolis ColtsA(4, 2–2) | Sun Life Stadium (5) | Miami Gardens, Florida (10) | 74,059 | Scott Green | |
| XLV | February 6, 2011 (2010) | Green Bay PackersN(5, 4–1) [W] | 31–25 | Pittsburgh SteelersA(8, 6–2) | Cowboys Stadium | Arlington, Texas | 103,219 | Walt Anderson | |
| XLVI | February 5, 2012 (2011) | New York GiantsN(5, 4–1) | 21–17 | New England PatriotsA(7, 3–4) | Lucas Oil Stadium | Indianapolis, Indiana | 68,658 | John Parry | |
| XLVII | February 3, 2013 (2012) | Baltimore RavensA(2, 2–0) | 34–31 | San Francisco 49ersN(6, 5–1) | Mercedes-Benz Superdome (7) | New Orleans, Louisiana (10) | 71,024 | Jerome Boger | |
| XLVIII | February 2, 2014 (2013) | Seattle SeahawksN(2, 1–1) | 43–8 | Denver BroncosA(7, 2–5) | MetLife Stadium | East Rutherford, New Jersey | 82,529 | Terry McAulay | |
| XLIX | February 1, 2015 (2014) | New England PatriotsA(8, 4–4) | 28–24 | Seattle SeahawksN(3, 1–2) | University of Phoenix Stadium (2) | Glendale, Arizona (3) | 70,288 | Bill Vinovich | |
