| Inductee | Class | Position | League(s) | Team(s) | Years |
| Harold "Red" Grange | 1963 | Halfback | AFL I | New York Yankees* | 1926 |
| Earl "Curly" Lambeau | 1963 | Founder | Independent | Green Bay Packers* | 1919 |
| Halfback | 1919–1920 |
| Coach | 1919–1920 |
| General Manager | 1919–1920 |
| Ray Flaherty | 1976 | Offensive End | AFL I | Los Angeles Wildcats | 1926 |
| Mike Michalske | 1964 | Guard Pre-Modern Era: Two-Way Performer | AFL I | New York Yankees* | 1926 |
| Art Rooney | 1964 | Owner / General Manager / Coach | Western Pennsylvania Professional Football Circuit | Hope-Harvey/ Majestic Radios/ J.P. Rooneys* (precursor to the Pittsburgh Steelers) | 1921–1932 |
| Ken Strong | 1967 | Halfback | AFL II | New York Yankees | 1936–1937 |
| American Association | Jersey City Giants | 1938, 1940 |
| Coach | 1938 |
| Paul Brown | 1967 | Coach / General Manager | All-America Football Conference | Cleveland Browns* | 1946–1949 |
| Sid Luckman | 1965 | Quarterback | American Association | Newark Bears | 1939 |
| George Halas | 1963 | End Pre-Modern Era: Two-Way Performer | Independent | Hammond All-Stars* | 1919 |
| Chicago Stayms | 1920 |
| John "Blood" McNally | 1963 | Halfback | AFL III | Buffalo Indians | 1941 |
| Jim Thorpe | 1963 | Halfback/Coach | Ohio League (Pre-NFL) | Canton Bulldogs* | 1915–17, 1919 |
| Independent | Tampa Cardinals | 1926 |
| Joseph Carr | 1963 | Coach | Independent | Columbus Panhandles* | 1901–1903 |
| Ohio League (Pre-NFL) | 1904, 1907–1918 |
| Team owner / General Manager | 1904, 1907–1919 |
| Jimmy Conzelman | 1964 | Coach | Independent | St. Louis Gunners* | 1931 |
| Guy Chamberlin | 1965 | End Pre-Modern Era: Two-Way Performer | Ohio League (Pre-NFL) | Canton Bulldogs* | 1919 |
| John "Paddy" Driscoll | 1965 | Quarterback | Independent | Hammond All-Stars/ Pros* | 1917, 1919 |
| Otto Graham | 1965 | Quarterback | All-America Football Conference | Cleveland Browns* | 1946–1949 |
| Joe Guyon | 1966 | Halfback | Ohio League (Pre-NFL) | Canton Bulldogs* | 1919 |
| Independent | Union Quakers of Philadelphia | 1921 |
| Steve Owen | 1966 | Tackle Pre-Modern Era: Two-Way Performer | Independent | Hartford Blues* | 1925 |
| Coach | Canadian Football League | Toronto Argonauts | 1959 |
| Calgary Stampeders | 1960 |
| Saskatchewan Roughriders | 1961–1962 |
| United Football League | Syracuse Stormers | 1963 |
| Elroy (Crazylegs) Hirsch | 1968 | Halfback | All-America Football Conference | Chicago Rockets | 1946–1948 |
| Marion Motley | 1968 | Fullback | All-America Football Conference | Cleveland Browns | 1946–1949 |
| Greasy Neale | 1969 | Coach | Ohio League (Pre-NFL) | Dayton Triangles* | 1918 |
| Independent | Ironton Tanks | 1930 |
| Joe Perry | 1969 | Fullback | All-America Football Conference | San Francisco 49ers* | 1948–1949 |
| Frank "Bruiser" Kinard | 1971 | Tackle Pre-Modern Era: Two-Way Performer | Independent/Military program | Fleet City Blue Jackets | 1945 |
| All-America Football Conference | New York Yankees | 1946–1947 |
| Vince Lombardi | 1971 | Guard | Independent | Wilmington Clippers | 1937 |
| American Association | Brooklyn Eagles | 1938 |
| Lamar Hunt | 1972 | AFL Co-founder | AFL (Pre-merger) | n/a | 1959 |
| Team owner | Dallas Texans/ Kansas City Chiefs* | 1959–1969 |
| Ace Parker | 1972 | Quarterback | All-America Football Conference | New York Yankees | 1946 |
| Lou Groza | 1974 | Offensive tackle / Kicker | All-America Football Conference | Cleveland Browns* | 1946–1949 |
| Dante Lavelli | 1975 | Offensive End | All-America Football Conference | Cleveland Browns* | 1946–1949 |
| Len Ford | 1976 | Defensive end | All-America Football Conference | Los Angeles Dons | 1948–1949 |
| Bill Willis | 1977 | Defensive Middle Guard | All-America Football Conference | Cleveland Browns* | 1946–1949 |
| Lance Alworth | 1978 | Flanker | AFL (Pre-merger) | San Diego Chargers* | 1962–1969 |