| Year | Award | Category | Work | Notes |
| 2010 | Young Hollywood Awards | Breakthrough of the Year | The Last Song | Won |
| Nickelodeon Australian Kids' Choice Awards | Favorite Kiss (with Miley Cyrus) |
| Cutest Couple (with Miley Cyrus) | Nominated |
| Teen Choice Awards | Choice Movie Breakout Star – Male | Won |
| Choice Movie – Liplock (with Miley Cyrus) | Nominated |
| Choice Movie – Drama |
| Choice Movie – Dance Scene (with Miley Cyrus) |
| Choice Movie – Chemistry (with Miley Cyrus) |
| 2012 | Choice Movie – Male Scene Stealer | The Hunger Games |
| People's Choice Awards | Favorite On Screen Chemistry (shared with Jennifer Lawrence and Josh Hutcherson) | Won |
| MTV Movie Awards | Best Breakthrough Performance | Nominated |
| Best Cast |
| Teen Choice Awards | Choice Hottie – Male |
| 2014 | The Hunger Games: Catching Fire |
| Choice Movie Actor – Sci-Fi |
| 2015 | The Hunger Games: Mockingjay – Part 1 |
| Choice Movie – Best Kiss (with Jennifer Lawrence) |
| 2017 | People's Choice Awards | Favorite Action Movie Actor | Independence Day: Resurgence |
| 2019 | Teen Choice Awards | Choice Movie Actor – Comedy | Isn't It Romantic |
| 2020 | Primetime Emmy Awards | Outstanding Short Form Comedy or Drama Series | Most Dangerous Game |
| 2016 | Golden Eye Award (Zurich Film Festival) | The New A-Lister | | Won |