| Episode | Theme | Song choice | Original artist | Order | Result |
| Audition | Auditioner's Choice | "(You Make Me Feel Like) A Natural Woman" | Aretha Franklin | — | Advanced |
| Hollywood Round, Part 1 | First Solo | "Get Me Bodied" | Beyoncé |
| Hollywood Round, Part 2 | Group Performance | Unaired |
| Hollywood Round, Part 3 | Second Solo |
| Las Vegas Round | Songs from the 1950s | "It Doesn't Matter Anymore"(with DeAndre Brackensick and Candice Glover) | Buddy Holly |
| Final Judgment | Final Solo | "The Prayer" | Celine Dion and Andrea Bocelli |
| Top 25 (12 Women) | Personal Choice | "Love You I Do" | Jennifer Hudson | 11 |
| Top 13 | Whitney Houston | "I Will Always Love You" | Dolly Parton | 12 | Safe |
| Top 11 | Year They Were Born | "Turn the Beat Around" | Vicki Sue Robinson | 2 |
| Top 10 | Billy Joel | "Everybody Has a Dream" | Billy Joel | 9 |
| Top 9 | Their Personal Idols | "Sweet Dreams" | Beyoncé | 7 |
| "Like a Prayer", "Borderline", and "Express Yourself"(with Hollie Cavanagh and Skylar Laine) | Madonna | 11 |
| Top 8 | Songs from the 1980s | Solo "How Will I Know" | Whitney Houston | 7 |
| "I Knew You Were Waiting (For Me)"(with Joshua Ledet) | Aretha Franklin and George Michael | 10 |
| Top 7 | Songs from the 2010s | "Stuttering" | Jazmine Sullivan | 3 | Saved |
| "Stronger (What Doesn't Kill You)"(with Joshua Ledet and Hollie Cavanagh) | Kelly Clarkson | 9 |
| Songs from Now & Then | "Fallin | Alicia Keys | 5 | Safe |
| "Try a Little Tenderness" | Ray Noble Orchestra | 12 |
| Top 6 | Queen | "Bohemian Rhapsody" | Queen | 1 |
| Contestant's Choice | "Dance with My Father" | Luther Vandross | 7 |
| Top 5 | Songs from the 1960s | "Proud Mary" | Creedence Clearwater Revival | 5 |
| "(Your Love Keeps Lifting Me) Higher and Higher"(with Hollie Cavanagh and Skylar Laine) | Jackie Wilson | 9 |
| British Pop | "You Are So Beautiful" | Billy Preston | 11 |
| Top 4 | California Dreamin' | "Steal Away" | Jimmy Hughes | 4 |
| "Eternal Flame"(with Hollie Cavanagh) | The Bangles | 6 |
| "Waiting for a Girl Like You"(with Hollie Cavanagh, Joshua Ledet, and Phillip Phillips) | Foreigner | 7 |
| Songs They Wish They'd Written | "And I Am Telling You I'm Not Going" | Jennifer Holliday | 11 |
| Top 3 | Judges' Choice | "My All" | Mariah Carey | 2 |
| Contestant's Choice | "I Don't Want to Miss a Thing" | Aerosmith | 5 |
| Jimmy Iovine's Choice | "I'll Be There" | The Jackson 5 | 8 |
| Finale | Simon Fuller's Choice | "I Have Nothing" | Whitney Houston | 1 | Runner-up |
| Favorite Performance | "The Prayer" | Celine Dion and Andrea Bocelli | 3 |
| Winner's Single | "Change Nothing" | Jessica Sanchez | 5 |
| mw- Due to the judges applying the "Judges' Save" on Sanchez, the top 7 remained intact for another week. Sanchez received the fewest votes; however, the judges applied the "Judges' Save" on her for her to remain in the competition. |
