| Year | Award | Category | Work | Result | Ref. |
| 2023 | Country Music Association Awards | Male Vocalist of the Year | Himself | Nominated | |
| New Artist of the Year | Won |
| Single of the Year | "Need a Favor" | Nominated |
| Music Video of the Year | Nominated |
| Musical Event of the Year | "Save Me" (with Lainey Wilson) | Nominated |
| CMT Music Awards | Male Video of the Year | "Son of a Sinner" | Won | |
| Male Breakthrough Video of the Year | Won |
| CMT Digital-First Performance of the Year | Won |
| 2024 | Grammy Awards | Best New Artist | Himself | Nominated | |
| Best Country Duo/Group Performance | "Save Me" (with Lainey Wilson) | Nominated |
| iHeartRadio Music Awards | Artist of the Year | Himself | Nominated | |
| Best New Pop Artist | Won |
| Best Alternative Rock Artist | Nominated |
| Best New Alternative Rock Artist | Nominated |
| Country Artist of the Year | Nominated |
| Best New Country Artist | Won |
| Rock Song of the Year | "Need a Favor" | Nominated |
| Favorite On Screen (Socially Voted) | "Save Me" | Nominated |
| People's Choice Awards | The Male Country Artist of the Year | Himself | Won | |
| The New Artist of the Year | Nominated |
| People's Choice Country Awards | The People's Artist of 2024 | Himself | Nominated | |
| The Male Artist of 2024 | Nominated |
| The Social Country Star of 2024 | Nominated |
| The Song of 2024 | "Wild Ones" (with Jessie Murph) | Nominated |
| The Collaboration Song of 2024 | "Chevrolet" (with Dustin Lynch) | Nominated |
| The Crossover Song of 2024 | "Lonely Road" (with Machine Gun Kelly) | Won |
| The Music Video of 2024 | Nominated |
| MTV Video Music Awards | Best Collaboration | "Wild Ones" (with Jessie Murph) | Nominated | |
| Video for Good | "Best for Me" (with Joyner Lucas) | Nominated |
| 2025 | Grammy Awards | Best Country Solo Performance | "I Am Not Okay" | Nominated |
| Best Country Song | Nominated |
| K-Love Fan Awards | Song of the Year | "Hard Fought Hallelujah" | Won | |
| GMA Dove Awards | Song of the Year | Won | |
| Short Form Music Video of the Year | Won | |
| Bluegrass/Country/Roots Recorded Song of the Year | Won | |
| MTV Video Music Awards | Best Country Video | "Liar" | Nominated | |
| Best Hip Hop Video | "Somebody Save Me" (with Eminem) | Nominated |
| Video for Good | Nominated |
| CMA Awards | Musical Event of the Year | "Hard Fought Hallelujah" | Nominated | |
| We Love Awards | Song of the Year | Nominated | |
| Contemporary Song of the Year | Nominated |
| Mainstream Impact Award | Won |
| "Bloodline" | Nominated |
| 2026 | Grammy Awards | Best Contemporary Country Album | Beautifully Broken | Won |
| Best Country Duo/Group Performance | "Amen" (with Shaboozey) | Won |
| Best Contemporary Christian Music Performance/Song | "Hard Fought Hallelujah" (with Brandon Lake) | Won |
