Topzle Topzle

Ideological leanings of United States Supreme Court justices

Updated: Wikipedia source

Ideological leanings of United States Supreme Court justices

The Supreme Court of the United States is the country's highest federal court. The Court has ultimate—and largely discretionary—appellate jurisdiction over all federal courts and state court cases involving issues of U.S. federal law, plus original jurisdiction over a small range of cases. The nine Supreme Court justices base their decisions on their interpretation of both legal doctrine and the precedential application of laws in the past. In most cases, interpreting the law is relatively clear-cut and the justices decide unanimously; however, in more complicated or controversial cases, the Court is often divided. In modern discourse, the justices of the Court are often categorized as having conservative, moderate, or liberal philosophies of law and of judicial interpretation. It has long been commonly assumed that justices' votes are a reflection of their judicial decision-making philosophy as well as their ideological leanings, personal attitudes, values, political philosophies, or policy preferences. A growing body of academic research has confirmed this understanding, as scholars have found that the justices largely vote in consonance with their perceived values. Analysts have used a variety of methods to deduce the specific perspective of each justice.

Tables

· Career liberal voting percentage by issue area from 1946–2017
85
85
No.
85
Justice
Fred M. Vinson
Year confirmed
1946
Year departed
1953
Position
Chief Justice
Criminal procedure
27.0%
Civil rights
45.3%
First amendment
26.2%
Union
34.1%
Econ­omic
59.9%
Feder­alism
51.5%
Federal taxes
74.5%
86
86
No.
86
Justice
Tom C. Clark
Year confirmed
1949
Year departed
1967
Position
Associate Justice
Criminal procedure
32.1%
Civil rights
53.5%
First amendment
37.1%
Union
61.9%
Econ­omic
72.5%
Feder­alism
51.3%
Federal taxes
74.8%
87
87
No.
87
Justice
Sherman Minton
Year confirmed
1949
Year departed
1956
Position
Associate Justice
Criminal procedure
23.1%
Civil rights
36.2%
First amendment
27.0%
Union
55.9%
Econ­omic
62.0%
Feder­alism
53.3%
Federal taxes
75.6%
88
88
No.
88
Justice
Earl Warren
Year confirmed
1953
Year departed
1969
Position
Chief Justice
Criminal procedure
73.3%
Civil rights
81.0%
First amendment
83.5%
Union
70.2%
Econ­omic
81.3%
Feder­alism
72.1%
Federal taxes
80.0%
89
89
No.
89
Justice
John Marshall Harlan II
Year confirmed
1955
Year departed
1971
Position
Associate Justice
Criminal procedure
37.8%
Civil rights
42.0%
First amendment
44.2%
Union
53.8%
Econ­omic
36.7%
Feder­alism
50.0%
Federal taxes
70.6%
90
90
No.
90
Justice
William J. Brennan Jr.
Year confirmed
1956
Year departed
1990
Position
Associate Justice
Criminal procedure
76.2%
Civil rights
82.5%
First amendment
84.5%
Union
65.8%
Econ­omic
69.8%
Feder­alism
66.3%
Federal taxes
70.3%
91
91
No.
91
Justice
Charles Evans Whittaker
Year confirmed
1957
Year departed
1962
Position
Associate Justice
Criminal procedure
39.8%
Civil rights
44.2%
First amendment
36.5%
Union
40.5%
Econ­omic
33.6%
Feder­alism
52.4%
Federal taxes
63.2%
92
92
No.
92
Justice
Potter Stewart
Year confirmed
1958
Year departed
1981
Position
Associate Justice
Criminal procedure
44.9%
Civil rights
48.4%
First amendment
63.0%
Union
57.3%
Econ­omic
45.0%
Feder­alism
56.5%
Federal taxes
66.4%
93
93
No.
93
Justice
Byron White
Year confirmed
1962
Year departed
1993
Position
Associate Justice
Criminal procedure
32.9%
Civil rights
55.2%
First amendment
39.2%
Union
62.6%
Econ­omic
59.3%
Feder­alism
66.9%
Federal taxes
84.7%
94
94
No.
94
Justice
Arthur Goldberg
Year confirmed
1962
Year departed
1965
Position
Associate Justice
Criminal procedure
75.0%
Civil rights
98.0%
First amendment
96.2%
Union
61.1%
Econ­omic
63.2%
Feder­alism
53.3%
Federal taxes
77.3%
95
95
No.
95
Justice
Abe Fortas
Year confirmed
1965
Year departed
1969
Position
Associate Justice
Criminal procedure
81.5%
Civil rights
82.1%
First amendment
79.5%
Union
60.0%
Econ­omic
72.2%
Feder­alism
64.3%
Federal taxes
46.7%
96
96
No.
96
Justice
Thurgood Marshall
Year confirmed
1967
Year departed
1991
Position
Associate Justice
Criminal procedure
80.1%
Civil rights
84.5%
First amendment
83.4%
Union
68.9%
Econ­omic
63.0%
Feder­alism
68.6%
Federal taxes
74.2%
97
97
No.
97
Justice
Warren E. Burger
Year confirmed
1969
Year departed
1986
Position
Chief Justice
Criminal procedure
19.0%
Civil rights
37.4%
First amendment
30.9%
Union
43.3%
Econ­omic
45.0%
Feder­alism
66.7%
Federal taxes
72.1%
98
98
No.
98
Justice
Harry Blackmun
Year confirmed
1970
Year departed
1994
Position
Associate Justice
Criminal procedure
42.3%
Civil rights
62.1%
First amendment
56.2%
Union
61.8%
Econ­omic
55.0%
Feder­alism
67.4%
Federal taxes
74.4%
99
99
No.
99
Justice
Lewis F. Powell Jr.
Year confirmed
1972
Year departed
1987
Position
Associate Justice
Criminal procedure
28.4%
Civil rights
40.3%
First amendment
46.1%
Union
51.1%
Econ­omic
45.6%
Feder­alism
59.0%
Federal taxes
56.1%
100
100
No.
100
Justice
William Rehnquist
Year confirmed
1972
Year departed
1986
Position
Associate Justice
Criminal procedure
14.1%
Civil rights
24.1%
First amendment
18.1%
Union
48.9%
Econ­omic
43.5%
Feder­alism
29.1%
Federal taxes
62.5%
101
101
No.
101
Justice
John Paul Stevens
Year confirmed
1975
Year departed
2010
Position
Associate Justice
Criminal procedure
66.9%
Civil rights
64.3%
First amendment
66.9%
Union
63.9%
Econ­omic
56.2%
Feder­alism
56.9%
Federal taxes
59.4%
102
102
No.
102
Justice
Sandra Day O'Connor
Year confirmed
1981
Year departed
2006
Position
Associate Justice
Criminal procedure
26.4%
Civil rights
45.4%
First amendment
41.8%
Union
42.7%
Econ­omic
46.5%
Feder­alism
48.3%
Federal taxes
58.9%
(100)
(100)
No.
(100)
Justice
William Rehnquist
Year confirmed
1986
Year departed
2005
Position
Chief Justice
Criminal procedure
19.6%
Civil rights
30.6%
First amendment
26.1%
Union
33.3%
Econ­omic
49.4%
Feder­alism
46.1%
Federal taxes
77.8%
103
103
No.
103
Justice
Antonin Scalia
Year confirmed
1986
Year departed
2016
Position
Associate Justice
Criminal procedure
27.4%
Civil rights
30.6%
First amendment
30.5%
Union
33.8%
Econ­omic
46.2%
Feder­alism
52.0%
Federal taxes
69.7%
104
104
No.
104
Justice
Anthony Kennedy
Year confirmed
1988
Year departed
2018
Position
Associate Justice
Criminal procedure
33.3%
Civil rights
44.0%
First amendment
46.0%
Union
39.7%
Econ­omic
44.6%
Feder­alism
56.3%
Federal taxes
81.0%
105
105
No.
105
Justice
David Souter
Year confirmed
1990
Year departed
2009
Position
Associate Justice
Criminal procedure
57.2%
Civil rights
69.3%
First amendment
70.8%
Union
58.8%
Econ­omic
54.2%
Feder­alism
64.8%
Federal taxes
70.7%
106
106
No.
106
Justice
Clarence Thomas
Year confirmed
1991
Year departed
Position
Associate Justice
Criminal procedure
22.4%
Civil rights
25.0%
First amendment
32.2%
Union
30.8%
Econ­omic
46.2%
Feder­alism
47.4%
Federal taxes
58.7%
107
107
No.
107
Justice
Ruth Bader Ginsburg
Year confirmed
1993
Year departed
2020
Position
Associate Justice
Criminal procedure
62.3%
Civil rights
70.0%
First amendment
69.4%
Union
72.2%
Econ­omic
56.6%
Feder­alism
60.6%
Federal taxes
80.6%
108
108
No.
108
Justice
Stephen Breyer
Year confirmed
1994
Year departed
2022
Position
Associate Justice
Criminal procedure
55.6%
Civil rights
69.7%
First amendment
55.8%
Union
77.1%
Econ­omic
50.0%
Feder­alism
67.7%
Federal taxes
79.4%
109
109
No.
109
Justice
John Roberts
Year confirmed
2005
Year departed
Position
Chief Justice
Criminal procedure
31.1%
Civil rights
42.4%
First amendment
50.0%
Union
41.2%
Econ­omic
44.5%
Feder­alism
73.2%
Federal taxes
90.9%
110
110
No.
110
Justice
Samuel Alito
Year confirmed
2006
Year departed
Position
Associate Justice
Criminal procedure
18.6%
Civil rights
38.8%
First amendment
39.0%
Union
31.3%
Econ­omic
42.4%
Feder­alism
68.4%
Federal taxes
81.8%
111
111
No.
111
Justice
Sonia Sotomayor
Year confirmed
2009
Year departed
Position
Associate Justice
Criminal procedure
66.9%
Civil rights
70.7%
First amendment
67.7%
Union
61.5%
Econ­omic
50.0%
Feder­alism
63.0%
Federal taxes
100.0%
112
112
No.
112
Justice
Elena Kagan
Year confirmed
2010
Year departed
Position
Associate Justice
Criminal procedure
62.5%
Civil rights
71.9%
First amendment
68.0%
Union
66.7%
Econ­omic
50.0%
Feder­alism
75.0%
Federal taxes
80.0%
113
113
No.
113
Justice
Neil Gorsuch
Year confirmed
2017
Year departed
Position
Associate Justice
Criminal procedure
0.0%
Civil rights
50.0%
First amendment
100.0%
Union
No cases
Econ­omic
33.3%
Feder­alism
No cases
Federal taxes
No cases
114
114
No.
114
Justice
Brett Kavanaugh
Year confirmed
2018
Year departed
Position
Associate Justice
115
115
No.
115
Justice
Amy Coney Barrett
Year confirmed
2020
Year departed
Position
Associate Justice
116
116
No.
116
Justice
Ketanji Brown Jackson
Year confirmed
2022
Year departed
Position
Associate Justice
No.
Justice
Year confirmed
Year departed
Position
Criminal procedure
Civil rights
First amendment
Union
Econ­omic
Feder­alism
Federal taxes
85
Fred M. Vinson
1946
1953
Chief Justice
27.0%
45.3%
26.2%
34.1%
59.9%
51.5%
74.5%
86
Tom C. Clark
1949
1967
Associate Justice
32.1%
53.5%
37.1%
61.9%
72.5%
51.3%
74.8%
87
Sherman Minton
1949
1956
Associate Justice
23.1%
36.2%
27.0%
55.9%
62.0%
53.3%
75.6%
88
Earl Warren
1953
1969
Chief Justice
73.3%
81.0%
83.5%
70.2%
81.3%
72.1%
80.0%
89
John Marshall Harlan II
1955
1971
Associate Justice
37.8%
42.0%
44.2%
53.8%
36.7%
50.0%
70.6%
90
William J. Brennan Jr.
1956
1990
Associate Justice
76.2%
82.5%
84.5%
65.8%
69.8%
66.3%
70.3%
91
Charles Evans Whittaker
1957
1962
Associate Justice
39.8%
44.2%
36.5%
40.5%
33.6%
52.4%
63.2%
92
Potter Stewart
1958
1981
Associate Justice
44.9%
48.4%
63.0%
57.3%
45.0%
56.5%
66.4%
93
Byron White
1962
1993
Associate Justice
32.9%
55.2%
39.2%
62.6%
59.3%
66.9%
84.7%
94
Arthur Goldberg
1962
1965
Associate Justice
75.0%
98.0%
96.2%
61.1%
63.2%
53.3%
77.3%
95
Abe Fortas
1965
1969
Associate Justice
81.5%
82.1%
79.5%
60.0%
72.2%
64.3%
46.7%
96
Thurgood Marshall
1967
1991
Associate Justice
80.1%
84.5%
83.4%
68.9%
63.0%
68.6%
74.2%
97
Warren E. Burger
1969
1986
Chief Justice
19.0%
37.4%
30.9%
43.3%
45.0%
66.7%
72.1%
98
Harry Blackmun
1970
1994
Associate Justice
42.3%
62.1%
56.2%
61.8%
55.0%
67.4%
74.4%
99
Lewis F. Powell Jr.
1972
1987
Associate Justice
28.4%
40.3%
46.1%
51.1%
45.6%
59.0%
56.1%
100
William Rehnquist
1972
1986
Associate Justice
14.1%
24.1%
18.1%
48.9%
43.5%
29.1%
62.5%
101
John Paul Stevens
1975
2010
Associate Justice
66.9%
64.3%
66.9%
63.9%
56.2%
56.9%
59.4%
102
Sandra Day O'Connor
1981
2006
Associate Justice
26.4%
45.4%
41.8%
42.7%
46.5%
48.3%
58.9%
(100)
William Rehnquist
1986
2005
Chief Justice
19.6%
30.6%
26.1%
33.3%
49.4%
46.1%
77.8%
103
Antonin Scalia
1986
2016
Associate Justice
27.4%
30.6%
30.5%
33.8%
46.2%
52.0%
69.7%
104
Anthony Kennedy
1988
2018
Associate Justice
33.3%
44.0%
46.0%
39.7%
44.6%
56.3%
81.0%
105
David Souter
1990
2009
Associate Justice
57.2%
69.3%
70.8%
58.8%
54.2%
64.8%
70.7%
106
Clarence Thomas
1991
Associate Justice
22.4%
25.0%
32.2%
30.8%
46.2%
47.4%
58.7%
107
Ruth Bader Ginsburg
1993
2020
Associate Justice
62.3%
70.0%
69.4%
72.2%
56.6%
60.6%
80.6%
108
Stephen Breyer
1994
2022
Associate Justice
55.6%
69.7%
55.8%
77.1%
50.0%
67.7%
79.4%
109
John Roberts
2005
Chief Justice
31.1%
42.4%
50.0%
41.2%
44.5%
73.2%
90.9%
110
Samuel Alito
2006
Associate Justice
18.6%
38.8%
39.0%
31.3%
42.4%
68.4%
81.8%
111
Sonia Sotomayor
2009
Associate Justice
66.9%
70.7%
67.7%
61.5%
50.0%
63.0%
100.0%
112
Elena Kagan
2010
Associate Justice
62.5%
71.9%
68.0%
66.7%
50.0%
75.0%
80.0%
113
Neil Gorsuch
2017
Associate Justice
0.0%
50.0%
100.0%
No cases
33.3%
No cases
No cases
114
Brett Kavanaugh
2018
Associate Justice
115
Amy Coney Barrett
2020
Associate Justice
116
Ketanji Brown Jackson
2022
Associate Justice

References

  1. To sort, click on the arrow in the header. To sort by multiple columns, click on the first column's sort arrow, then shi
  2. William Rehnquist's terms as associate justice and chief justice are listed separately.
  3. Percentages for Neil Gorsuch may be misleading since he had participated in only a few cases through 2017.
  4. The Supreme Court and the Attitudinal Model Revisited
  5. Emory Law Journal
    https://web.archive.org/web/20121009210216/http://www.law.emory.edu/fileadmin/journals/elj/61/61.4/Epstein_Martin.pdf
  6. Journal of Public Economics
    https://www.econstor.eu/bitstream/10419/185462/1/cesifo1_wp7264.pdf
  7. Political Research Quarterly
    https://doi.org/10.1177%2F106591290005300306
  8. The Justice System Journal
    https://www.danpinello.com/linking-party-to-judicial-ideology-in-american-courts
  9. Epstein, Lee
    https://static1.squarespace.com/static/60188505fb790b33c3d33a61/t/685f50748be9977089829a96/1751076981684/2024termdatareport.pdf
  10. The Supreme Court Review
    https://www.journals.uchicago.edu/doi/pdf/10.1086/691096
  11. The company they keep: How partisan divisions came to the Supreme Court
    https://wwws.law.northwestern.edu/research-faculty/events/colloquium/public-law/documents/devins_baum_the%20company%20they%20keep.pdf
  12. Pepperdine Law Review
    https://digitalcommons.pepperdine.edu/plr/vol51/iss3/2
  13. New York Times
    https://www.nytimes.com/2024/07/02/us/politics/supreme-court-term-decisions.html
  14. Five Thirty Eight
    https://fivethirtyeight.com/features/the-supreme-courts-partisan-divide-hasnt-been-this-sharp-in-generations/
  15. Journal of Economic Perspectives
    https://doi.org/10.1257%2Fjep.35.1.97
  16. American Political Science Review
    http://www.uic.edu/classes/pols/pols200mm/Segal89.pdf
  17. The Journal of Politics
    https://scholar.princeton.edu/sites/default/files/ccameron/files/segal.etal_.jop_.aug1995.pdf
  18. American Journal of Political Science
    https://web.archive.org/web/20100621194219/http://epstein.law.northwestern.edu/research/cjdisputes.pdf
  19. American Law and Economics Review
    https://chicagounbound.uchicago.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=2440&=&context=law_and_economics
  20. Public Choice
    http://www.socsci.uci.edu/~bgrofman/14%20Grofman-Brazill-Median%20Justice.pdf
  21. "The Unidimensional Supreme Court"
    http://voteview.com/the_unidimensional_supreme_court.htm
  22. Missouri Law Review
    https://web.archive.org/web/20100601155120/http://law.missouri.edu/lawreview/docs/70-4/Ruger.pdf
  23. The Journal of Law, Economics, & Organization
    http://169.229.248.216/files/prefchange.pdf
  24. Northwestern University Law Review
    http://mqscores.wustl.edu/media/PrefChange.pdf
  25. International Encyclopedia of Political Science
    https://web.archive.org/web/20131112194926/http://jackman.stanford.edu/papers/download.php?i=6
  26. Political Analysis
    http://adm.wustl.edu/media/pdfs/pa02.pdf
  27. The Judicial Mind
    https://www.researchgate.net/publication/2403516
  28. North Carolina Law Review
    http://scholarship.law.berkeley.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=2604&context=facpubs
  29. FiveThirtyEight
    https://fivethirtyeight.com/features/supreme-court-may-be-most-conservative-in-modern-history/
  30. "Martin–Quinn scores: measures"
    http://mqscores.wustl.edu/measures.php
  31. Journal of Political Economy
    https://doi.org/10.1086%2F256633
  32. The Journal of Politics
    https://www.researchgate.net/publication/259434415
  33. The constrained court: law, politics, and the decisions justices make
  34. American Political Science Review
    http://www.cs.princeton.edu/courses/archive/fall09/cos597A/papers/ClintonJackmanRivers2004.pdf
  35. Journal of Law, Economics, and Organization
    https://web.archive.org/web/20101008045555/http://epstein.law.northwestern.edu/research/JCS.pdf
  36. American Journal of Political Science
    http://www9.georgetown.edu/faculty/baileyma/ajps_offprint_bailey.pdf
  37. "Updated Bridge Ideal Points for 1950 to 2020 (updated May 2021)"
    https://michaelbailey.georgetown.domains/bridge-ideal-points-2020/
  38. California Law Review
    https://web.archive.org/web/20101209182527/http://www.californialawreview.org/assets/pdfs/98-3/HoQuinn.Mac.pdf
  39. Legislative Studies Quarterly
    https://web.archive.org/web/20130330001043/http://voteview.com/nominatevideal.pdf
  40. United States Courts
    https://www.uscourts.gov/about-federal-courts/educational-resources/about-educational-outreach/activity-resources/supreme-1
  41. "The Supreme Court at Work: The Term and Caseload"
    https://www.supremecourt.gov/about/courtatwork.aspx
  42. Columbia Law Review
    https://columbialawreview.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/04/Johnson-The_Origins_Of_Supreme_Court_Question_Selection.pdf
  43. Northwestern University Law Review
    https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=1000986
  44. The Journal of Politics
    http://mcguire.web.unc.edu/files/2014/01/policy_content.pdf
  45. Reuters
    https://www.reuters.com/article/legal-us-usa-court-shadow-video/the-shadow-docket-how-the-u-s-supreme-court-quietly-dispatches-key-rulings-idUSKBN2BF16Q
  46. The New York Times
    https://www.nytimes.com/2010/07/25/us/25roberts.html?pagewanted=all
  47. Minnesota Law Review
    http://www.minnesotalawreview.org/wp-content/uploads/2013/04/EpsteinLanderPosner_MLR.pdf
  48. FiveThirtyEight
    https://fivethirtyeight.com/features/the-supreme-courts-partisan-divide-hasnt-been-this-sharp-in-generations/
  49. CNBC
    https://www.cnbc.com/2022/06/30/supreme-court-justice-ketanji-brown-jackson-sworn-in-replaces-breyer.html
  50. The New York Times
    https://www.nytimes.com/2021/06/18/us/politics/supreme-court-conservatives-liberals.html
  51. "The U.S. Supreme Court Justices Database"
    https://web.archive.org/web/20171118091907/http://epstein.wustl.edu/research/justicesdata.html
  52. "2023 Supreme Court Database"
    http://supremecourtdatabase.org/
Image
Source:
Tip: Wheel or +/− to zoom, drag to pan, Esc to close.