| Year | Award | Category | Nominated work | Result | Ref. |
| 2015 | NYMF Award | Outstanding Individual Performance | Claudio Quest | Nominated | |
| 2018 | Tony Award | Best Actor in a Musical | SpongeBob SquarePants | Nominated | |
| Drama Desk Award | Outstanding Actor in a Musical | Won | |
| Outer Critics Circle Award | Outstanding Actor in a Musical | Won | |
| Broadway.com Audience Awards | Favorite Breakthrough Performance (Male) | Won | |
| Favorite Leading Actor in a Musical | Won |
| Theatre World Award | Honoree | |
| 2022 | Lucille Lortel Award | Outstanding Featured Performer in a Musical | Assassins | Nominated | |
| 2024 | Alliance of Women Film Journalists | Best Ensemble Cast | Wicked | Nominated | |
| Astra Film Awards | Best Cast Ensemble | Nominated | |
| Las Vegas Film Critics Society | Best Ensemble | Nominated | |
| Michigan Movie Critics Guild | Best Ensemble | Nominated | |
| New York Film Critics Online | Best Ensemble | Nominated | |
| San Diego Film Critics Society | Best Ensemble | Nominated | |
| Screen Actors Guild Awards | Best Ensemble | Nominated | |
| St. Louis Film Critics Association | Best Ensemble | Nominated | |
| Washington D.C. Area Film Critics Association | Best Acting Ensemble | Nominated | |