| Year | Award | Result |
| 2005 | Praise & Worship Album of the Year (Arriving) | Won |
| 2006 | Artist of the Year | Won |
| Male Vocalist of the Year | Won |
| Song of the Year ("Holy Is the Lord") | Nominated |
| Song of the Year ("How Great Is Our God") | Won |
| Worship Song of the Year ("Holy Is the Lord") | Nominated |
| Worship Song of the Year ("How Great Is Our God") | Won |
| Worship Song of the Year ("Indescribable")1 | Nominated |
| Special Event Album of the Year (Music Inspired by The Chronicles of Narnia)* | Won |
| Special Event Album of the Year (Passion: How Great Is Our God)* | Nominated |
| Special Event Album of the Year (WOW Christmas: Green)* | Nominated |
| 2007 | Artist of the Year | Won |
| Male Vocalist of the Year | Won |
| Song of the Year ("Made to Worship") | Nominated |
| Pop/Contemporary Recorded Song of the Year ("Made to Worship") | Nominated |
| Pop/Contemporary Album of the Year (See The Morning) | Won |
| Worship Song of the Year ("Holy Is the Lord") | Won |
| Worship Song of the Year ("Made to Worship") | Nominated |
| Praise & Worship Album of the Year (See The Morning) | Won |
| Special Event Album of the Year (Passion: Everything Glorious)* | Won |
| 2008 | Artist of the Year | Nominated |
| Male Vocalist of the Year | Won |
| Song of the Year ("Amazing Grace (My Chains Are Gone)") | Nominated |
| Worship Song of the Year ("Amazing Grace (My Chains Are Gone)") | Nominated |
| Worship Song of the Year ("How Great Is Our God") | Won |
| Special Event Album of the Year (Music Inspired By the Motion Picture Amazing Grace)* | Nominated |
| 2009 | Artist of the Year | Nominated |
| Male Vocalist of the Year | Nominated |
| Song of the Year ("Amazing Grace (My Chains Are Gone)") | Nominated |
| Worship Song of the Year ("Jesus Messiah") | Nominated |
| Praise & Worship Album of the Year (Hello Love) | Nominated |
| Special Event Album of the Year (Passion: God of This City)* | Won |
| Contemporary Gospel Recorded Song of the Year ("How Great Is Our God")2 | Won |
| 2010 | Song of the Year ("I Will Rise") | Nominated |
| Worship Song of the Year ("I Will Rise") | Nominated |
| Praise & Worship Album of the Year (Hello Love) | Nominated |
| Christmas Album of the Year (Glory in the Highest: Christmas Songs of Worship) | Nominated |
| 2011 | Artist of the Year | Nominated |
| Male Vocalist of the Year | Nominated |
| Song of the Year ("Our God") | Nominated |
| Worship Song of the Year ("Our God") | Won |
| Special Event Album of the Year (Passion: Awakening)* | Won |
| 2012 | Praise & Worship Album of the Year (And If Our God Is For Us...) | Won |
| 2013 | Song of the Year ("Whom Shall I Fear [God of Angel Armies]") | Nominated |
| Praise & Worship Album of the Year ("Burning Lights") | Won |
| Pop/Contemporary Album of the Year ("Burning Lights") | Nominated |
| Artist of the Year | Nominated |
| Special Event Album of the Year (Passion: White Flag)* | Nominated |
| Special Event Album of the Year (Passion: Let The Future Begin)* | Won |