| Year | Award | Category | Work | Result |
| 2010 | AFI Awards | TV Program of the Year | Glee (with Ryan Murphy and Ian Brennan) | Won |
| 2011 | Won |
| 2011 | British Academy Television Awards | Best International | Nominated |
| 2011 | National Television Awards | Digital Choice | Nominated |
| 2010 | Primetime Emmy Awards | Outstanding Writing for a Comedy Series | Nominated |
| Outstanding Comedy Series | Glee (with Ryan Murphy, Ian Brennan, Dante Di Loreto, Bradley Buecker, Alexis Martin Woodall and Kenneth J. Silverstein) | Nominated |
| 2011 | Glee (with Ryan Murphy, Ian Brennan, Dante Di Loreto, Bradley Buecker, Alexis Martin Woodall, Kenneth J. Silverstein and Michael Novick) | Nominated |
| 2012 | Outstanding Miniseries or Movie | American Horror Story: Murder House (with Ryan Murphy, Dante Di Loreto, Bradley Buecker, Alexis Martin Woodall and Chip Vucelich) | Nominated |
| 2013 | American Horror Story: Asylum (with Ryan Murphy, Dante Di Loreto, Tim Minear, Jennifer Salt, James Wong, Jessica Sharzer, Bradley Buecker, Alexis Martin Woodall and Chip Vucelich) | Nominated |
| 2014 | Outstanding Writing for a Miniseries, Movie or a Dramatic Special | American Horror Story: Coven (with Ryan Murphy for the episode "Bitchcraft") | Nominated |
| Outstanding Miniseries | American Horror Story: Coven (with Ryan Murphy, Dante Di Loreto, Bradley Buecker, Alexis Martin Woodall and Chip Vucelich) | Nominated |
| 2015 | Outstanding Limited Series | American Horror Story: Freak Show (with Ryan Murphy, Dante Di Loreto, Tim Minear, Jennifer Salt, James Wong, Bradley Buecker, Jessica Sharzer, Alexis Martin Woodall and Robert M. Williams Jr.) | Nominated |
| 2016 | The People v. O. J. Simpson: American Crime Story (with Ryan Murphy, Nina Jacobson, Brad Simpson, Scott Alexander, Larry Karaszewski, D.V. DeVincentis, Anthony Hemingway, Alexis Martin Woodall, John Travolta und Chip Vucelich) | Won |
| 2018 | The Assassination of Gianni Versace: American Crime Story (with Ryan Murphy, Nina Jacobson, Brad Simpson, Alexis Martin Woodall, Tom Rob Smith, Daniel Minahan, Scott Alexander, Larry Karaszewski, Chip Vucelich, Eric Kovtun, Lou Eyrich and Eryn Krueger Mekash) | Won |
| 2021 | Outstanding Drama Series | Pose (with Ryan Murphy, Nina Jacobson, Brad Simpson, Alexis Martin Woodall, Sherry Marsh, Steven Canals, Janet Mock, Our Lady J, Tanase Popa, Lou Eyrich, Jeff Dickerson, Todd Nenninger and Kip Davis Myers) | Nominated |
| Outstanding Writing for a Drama Series | Pose (with Steven Canals, Our Lady J, Janet Mock, and Ryan Murphy for the episode "Series Finale") | Nominated |
| 2011 | Producers Guild of America Awards | Outstanding Producer of Episodic Television, Comedy | Glee (with Ian Brennan, Dante Di Loreto, Ryan Murphy and Kenneth J. Silverstein) | Nominated |
| 2012 | Nominated |
| 2013 | Outstanding Producer of Long-Form Television | American Horror Story: Asylum (with Bradley Buecker, Dante Di Loreto, Alexis Martin Woodall, Ryan Murphy and Chip Vucelich) | Nominated |
| 2014 | American Horror Story: Coven (with Bradley Buecker, Dante Di Loreto, Ryan Murphy, Chip Vucelich and Alexis Martin Woodall) | Nominated |
| 2010 | TV Quick Awards | Best New Drama | Glee (with Ryan Murphy and Ian Brennan) | Won |
| 2011 | Best Drama Series | Nominated |
| 2010 | Writers Guild of America Awards | New Series | Nominated |
| Comedy Series | Nominated |
| 2011 | Nominated |
| 2020 | Valentine Davies Award | |
